Oscar Contender 'The Brutalist' Sparks AI Controversy

29 Sources

The film 'The Brutalist' faces backlash for using AI to enhance actors' Hungarian accents, raising questions about authenticity in performances and the role of AI in filmmaking.

News article

AI Controversy Surrounds Oscar Contender 'The Brutalist'

'The Brutalist', a frontrunner for this year's Academy Awards, has found itself at the center of a heated debate in Hollywood. The controversy erupted when the film's editor, Dávid Jancsó, revealed that artificial intelligence was used to enhance the Hungarian spoken by lead actors Adrien Brody and Felicity Jones 1.

The Use of AI in 'The Brutalist'

The epic drama, directed by Brady Corbet, follows a Hungarian Jewish architect (played by Brody) who survives the Holocaust and immigrates to America. Given the centrality of language to the story, the production partnered with Ukrainian software company Respeecher to tweak and augment Brody and Jones' Hungarian accents 1.

Jancsó, a native Hungarian speaker, explained that the decision was made due to the difficulty of pronouncing Hungarian accurately. The AI tool was used primarily to replace certain letters and vowel sounds, aiming to make the actors sound like native speakers 2.

Artistic Intent vs. Authenticity Concerns

The filmmakers argue that the use of AI was driven by artistic intent. Director Brady Corbet stated that the aim was to "preserve the authenticity of Adrien and Felicity's performances in another language, not to replace or alter them" 2. Rupal Patel, a professor at Northeastern University, supports this view, suggesting that the decision makes the film more inclusive for Hungarian viewers 1.

Industry Backlash and Concerns

However, the revelation has sparked significant backlash within the industry and among viewers. Critics argue that using AI to modify accents undermines the authenticity of actors' performances and raises concerns about the future of human creativity in filmmaking 3.

The controversy touches on broader industry concerns about AI's role in film production, which were central to the 2023 SAG-AFTRA strike. The strike resulted in tentative agreements aimed at regulating AI use in the film industry 3.

Implications for Awards Season

Despite the controversy, 'The Brutalist' received 10 Oscar nominations, including nods for Brody and Jones in the acting categories 4. This success has somewhat blunted the criticism, but the debate continues about whether AI-aided performances should be eligible for such accolades.

Broader Context of AI in Film

'The Brutalist' is not alone in its use of AI. Other films, including the musical 'Emilia Pérez', have also employed similar technologies 5. As the industry grapples with these new tools, questions arise about the balance between technological advancement and preserving the essence of human performance in cinema.

The controversy surrounding 'The Brutalist' highlights the ongoing tension between technological innovation and traditional notions of artistry in filmmaking. As AI continues to evolve, the industry will need to navigate these challenges carefully, balancing the benefits of new technologies with the preservation of authentic human creativity.

Explore today's top stories

Amazon Acquires Bee: AI Wearable That Records Everything You Say

Amazon is set to acquire Bee, a startup that produces an AI-enabled wearable device capable of recording and analyzing conversations. This move signals Amazon's renewed interest in the AI wearables market.

TechCrunch logoThe Verge logoPC Magazine logo

19 Sources

Technology

23 hrs ago

Amazon Acquires Bee: AI Wearable That Records Everything

Proton Launches Lumo: A Privacy-First AI Assistant with End-to-End Encryption

Proton, known for its privacy-focused services, introduces Lumo, an AI chatbot that prioritizes user privacy through end-to-end encryption and zero-log policies.

TechCrunch logoCNET logoThe Verge logo

13 Sources

Technology

14 hrs ago

Proton Launches Lumo: A Privacy-First AI Assistant with

Google DeepMind's Aeneas AI: Revolutionizing Ancient Latin Inscription Analysis

Google DeepMind's new AI model, Aeneas, is transforming the study of ancient Latin inscriptions by restoring fragmented texts, predicting origins, and providing contextual insights.

Nature logoNew Scientist logoScience News logo

10 Sources

Science and Research

7 hrs ago

Google DeepMind's Aeneas AI: Revolutionizing Ancient Latin

Teens Increasingly Turn to AI Companions for Advice and Friendship, Raising Concerns

A new study reveals that over 70% of American teenagers are using AI companions for personal advice and emotional support, sparking concerns about the impact on real-world relationships and mental health.

AP NEWS logoTech Xplore logoFortune logo

15 Sources

Technology

23 hrs ago

Teens Increasingly Turn to AI Companions for Advice and

Google Expands AI-Powered Photo-to-Video Features Across YouTube Shorts and Google Photos

Google introduces new AI-driven features for transforming photos into videos and creating artistic remixes in YouTube Shorts and Google Photos, powered by its Veo 2 model.

Ars Technica logoTechCrunch logoThe Verge logo

14 Sources

Technology

7 hrs ago

Google Expands AI-Powered Photo-to-Video Features Across
TheOutpost.ai

Your Daily Dose of Curated AI News

Don’t drown in AI news. We cut through the noise - filtering, ranking and summarizing the most important AI news, breakthroughs and research daily. Spend less time searching for the latest in AI and get straight to action.

© 2025 Triveous Technologies Private Limited
Instagram logo
LinkedIn logo