AI actor Tilly Norwood releases music video that critics call the worst song ever heard

14 Sources

Share

Particle6's AI-generated character Tilly Norwood has released a music video titled Take the Lead, and the reception has been brutal. Critics are calling it the worst song they've ever heard, with lyrics defending AI's role in entertainment while the video struggles to gain traction—just 4,000 views in four hours. The release intensifies debates about AI in entertainment and whether AI creations can replace human creative workers.

AI-Generated Character Sparks Fresh Controversy

Tilly Norwood, the AI-generated character created by production company Particle6, has released a music video that is drawing widespread criticism across the entertainment industry

1

. The AI actor, who first appeared last fall and was marketed as a potential competitor to flesh-and-blood performers, dropped the video for Take the Lead ahead of the Oscars

3

. TechCrunch's assessment was blunt: "Upon listening to it, I actually think it is the worst song I have ever heard"

1

. The Tilly Norwood music video represents a new chapter in the ongoing battle over AI in entertainment, one that appears to be backfiring spectacularly for its creators.

Source: New York Post

Source: New York Post

Lyrics That Miss the Mark on Human Experience

The Take the Lead song opens with Norwood singing, "When they talk about me, they don't see/The human spark, the creativity"

1

. The lyrics directly address the backlash against AI, with Norwood insisting, "They say it's not real, that it's fake/But I am still human, make no mistake"

1

. Critics point out the fundamental problem: the song attempts to create empathy for an experience no human will ever have. The chorus includes a rallying cry to other AI creations: "Actors, it's time to take the lead/Create the future, plant the seed/Don't be left out, don't fall behind/Build your own, and you'll be free"

1

. The song culminates with the message that "AI's not the enemy, it's the key," a claim that has only intensified criticism

3

.

Production Details and Lackluster Reception

Despite a title card claiming 18 real humans worked on the production, the music was generated using Suno, an AI platform, while the video was produced using AI tools and performance capture

4

. Eline van der Velden, founder of Particle6 and creator of the AI-generated character, acted out Norwood's movements and expressions for the performance capture

4

. The four-minute video shows Norwood performing atop London rooftops, in a bathtub, and flying through the sky on a flamingo-shaped inflatable

4

. Yet the numbers tell a different story about its appeal: at the time of publication, the video had garnered just over 4,000 views in four hours, with around 80 comments, most of them negative

3

. Norwood's social media presence remains minimal, with under 4,000 YouTube subscribers, just 3 TikTok followers, and nearly 90,000 Instagram followers

3

.

Source: THR

Source: THR

Industry Backlash Intensifies

The entertainment industry has not welcomed AI creations in entertainment with open arms. When Particle6 first introduced Tilly Norwood last fall, Golden Globe winner Emily Blunt responded in a Variety interview: "Good Lord, we're screwed. Come on, agencies, don't do that. Please stop"

1

. SAG-AFTRA, one of the largest unions representing human creative workers, issued a strong statement condemning the AI actor: "'Tilly Norwood' is not an actor; it's a character generated by a computer program that was trained on the work of countless professional performers -- without permission or compensation. It has no life experience to draw from, no emotion and, from what we've seen, audiences aren't interested in watching computer-generated content untethered from the human experience"

1

. Multiple talent agencies announced they wouldn't represent the photorealistic AI character, and several actors threatened to boycott any agency that signed Norwood

3

.

Technical Flaws Expose AI Limitations

Beyond the lyrical content, critics have identified numerous technical problems that expose the limitations of current AI tools. TechRadar noted that Norwood "doesn't know how to sing," performing without blinking or breathing properly, and at one point clearly inhaling while singing—a physical impossibility for human performers

5

. The video displays what critics describe as the "standard AI sheen" where things look technically good but fall apart under scrutiny, such as falling dollar bills with completely unintelligible symbols

3

. Polygon compared the video unfavorably to Rebecca Black's widely mocked Friday, saying it makes that song look like Beyoncé's Formation

2

. The Los Angeles Times suggested the video is so bad that actors needn't worry about AI creations putting them out of work

2

.

Source: Polygon

Source: Polygon

Concerns About Training Data and Human Artistry

The backlash against AI highlights deeper concerns about copyright concerns and the use of training data without consent. SAG-AFTRA's statement emphasized that the AI-generated character creates "the problem of using stolen performances to put actors out of work, jeopardizing performer livelihoods and devaluing human artistry"

1

. TechCrunch drew parallels to Pitchfork's infamous 0.0 review of Jet's album, noting that while Jet was merely derivative, "Tilly Norwood is literally derived from AI models that could not exist without the training data that tech companies took from artists without their consent"

1

. These issues around AI guardrails and compensation remain central to ongoing debates in creative fields.

What's Next for the Tillyverse

Van der Velden has defended the project, stating that "Tilly is, and has always been, a vehicle to test the creative capabilities and boundaries of AI -- not take anyone's job"

4

. She emphasized that "great AI content isn't instant -- it always takes good ideas, taste, direction, judgment and time. In other words: people remain at the heart of it"

4

. Particle6 has announced plans for the Tillyverse, an entertainment world where AI characters "live, interact, and work," with Norwood's planned acting debut later this year

4

. The video's description hints at a potential Oscars appearance, asking, "Does anyone know if they have free valet parking for my flamingo?"

3

. Since introducing the character, Particle6 has yet to produce anything longer than four minutes, raising questions about whether Hollywood will embrace or reject this vision of AI in entertainment. For now, the overwhelmingly negative response suggests audiences remain firmly on the side of human performers.

Today's Top Stories

TheOutpost.ai

Your Daily Dose of Curated AI News

Don’t drown in AI news. We cut through the noise - filtering, ranking and summarizing the most important AI news, breakthroughs and research daily. Spend less time searching for the latest in AI and get straight to action.

© 2026 Triveous Technologies Private Limited
Instagram logo
LinkedIn logo