OpenAI's GPT-5 Launch Marred by Chart Controversies and Data Visualization Errors

Reviewed byNidhi Govil

2 Sources

OpenAI's GPT-5 launch presentation featured misleading charts and data visualization errors, sparking criticism and raising questions about the AI industry's approach to presenting performance metrics.

OpenAI's GPT-5 Launch Presentation Sparks Controversy

OpenAI's recent unveiling of GPT-5, the latest version of its AI language model, has been overshadowed by a series of data visualization errors in the presentation charts. The incident has sparked widespread criticism and mockery, raising questions about the AI industry's approach to presenting performance metrics 1.

The Chart Crimes

During the GPT-5 demonstration, OpenAI displayed several confusing and dubious graphics. One chart appeared to show that 52.8% was larger than 69.1%, which was somehow equal to 30.8%. This glaring error quickly became the subject of ridicule on social media platforms 1.

Source: pcgamer

Source: pcgamer

Another chart comparing the "coding deception" rates of GPT-5 and OpenAI o3 showed inconsistent bar heights that did not accurately represent the percentages. The bar for OpenAI o3 (47.4%) was rendered roughly three times higher than that of GPT-5 (50%), despite the latter having a higher percentage 2.

Industry-wide Problem

The chart controversies extend beyond OpenAI. Anthropic, another AI startup, presented a chart comparing accuracy rates of its AI chatbot Claude, where the scale started at 50% instead of zero. This technique, frowned upon by data visualization experts, can magnify small differences and potentially mislead viewers 1.

Expert Opinions

Alberto Cairo, a professor of visualization design at the University of Miami, described the charts as "terrible." He criticized not only the arithmetic errors but also the unnecessary use of graphs for small sets of numbers that could be easily understood without visual aids 1.

Jessica Dai, a PhD student at UC Berkeley's AI research lab, pointed out the hypocrisy in Anthropic's approach. The company had previously advocated for including confidence intervals in AI evaluations but failed to follow its own recommendation in this instance 1.

Broader Implications

These visualization errors have reignited discussions about the AI industry's tendency to use confidently expressed but unverified data to boast about technology or criticize competitors. Previous instances of such behavior include AI detection companies claiming untested high accuracy rates and Meta allegedly gaming its AI to improve its standings in a technology scoreboard 1.

OpenAI's Response

OpenAI has since attempted to address the issues by posting updated charts on its website. However, these revisions have raised further questions. A disclaimer added to the SWE-bench chart revealed that the figures were based on 477 tasks instead of the full 500, leading some observers to speculate whether inconvenient tasks were omitted to edge out competitors 2.

Sam Altman, OpenAI's CEO, apologized on Reddit for the "unintentional chart crime," attributing the errors to staff rushing to complete their work 1.

Conclusion

The chart controversies surrounding OpenAI's GPT-5 launch have highlighted ongoing issues within the AI industry regarding data representation and transparency. As the field continues to advance rapidly, these incidents serve as a reminder of the need for rigorous standards in presenting AI performance metrics to the public and stakeholders.

Explore today's top stories

NVIDIA Unveils Major GeForce NOW Upgrade with RTX 5080 Performance and Expanded Game Library

NVIDIA announces significant upgrades to its GeForce NOW cloud gaming service, including RTX 5080-class performance, improved streaming quality, and an expanded game library, set to launch in September 2025.

CNET logoengadget logoPCWorld logo

9 Sources

Technology

7 hrs ago

NVIDIA Unveils Major GeForce NOW Upgrade with RTX 5080

Space: The New Frontier of 21st Century Warfare

As nations compete for dominance in space, the risk of satellite hijacking and space-based weapons escalates, transforming outer space into a potential battlefield with far-reaching consequences for global security and economy.

AP NEWS logoTech Xplore logoeuronews logo

7 Sources

Technology

1 day ago

Space: The New Frontier of 21st Century Warfare

OpenAI Tweaks GPT-5 to Be 'Warmer and Friendlier' Amid User Backlash

OpenAI updates GPT-5 to make it more approachable following user feedback, sparking debate about AI personality and user preferences.

ZDNet logoTom's Guide logoFuturism logo

6 Sources

Technology

16 hrs ago

OpenAI Tweaks GPT-5 to Be 'Warmer and Friendlier' Amid User

Russian Disinformation Campaign Exploits AI to Spread Fake News

A pro-Russian propaganda group, Storm-1679, is using AI-generated content and impersonating legitimate news outlets to spread disinformation, raising concerns about the growing threat of AI-powered fake news.

Rolling Stone logoBenzinga logo

2 Sources

Technology

1 day ago

Russian Disinformation Campaign Exploits AI to Spread Fake

AI in Healthcare: Patients Trust AI Medical Advice Over Doctors, Raising Concerns and Challenges

A study reveals patients' increasing reliance on AI for medical advice, often trusting it over doctors. This trend is reshaping doctor-patient dynamics and raising concerns about AI's limitations in healthcare.

ZDNet logoMedscape logoEconomic Times logo

3 Sources

Health

15 hrs ago

AI in Healthcare: Patients Trust AI Medical Advice Over
TheOutpost.ai

Your Daily Dose of Curated AI News

Don’t drown in AI news. We cut through the noise - filtering, ranking and summarizing the most important AI news, breakthroughs and research daily. Spend less time searching for the latest in AI and get straight to action.

© 2025 Triveous Technologies Private Limited
Instagram logo
LinkedIn logo