AI-Generated Lawyer Avatar Sparks Controversy in New York Courtroom

2 Sources

A 74-year-old plaintiff's attempt to use an AI-generated lawyer avatar in a New York courtroom backfires, raising questions about the use of artificial intelligence in legal proceedings.

News article

AI-Generated Lawyer Causes Stir in New York Courtroom

In a surprising turn of events, a New York courtroom became the stage for an unprecedented clash between artificial intelligence and legal tradition. Jerome Dewald, a 74-year-old plaintiff, attempted to use an AI-generated lawyer avatar during his court appearance, catching the judge and court officials off guard 12.

The Controversial Presentation

Dewald, who was representing himself in an employment dispute with insurance company MassMutual Metro, had received permission from the court to play a video presentation. However, he failed to disclose that the video would feature an AI-generated avatar named James 1. As the video began playing, the well-groomed, sweater-wearing AI avatar addressed the court:

"Now may it please the court, I come here today a humble pro se before a panel of five distinguished justices" 2.

Judge's Swift Intervention

Associate Justice Sallie Manzanet-Daniels quickly intervened, expressing confusion and displeasure upon realizing that the "lawyer" was not a real person 12. The judge chastised Dewald for not disclosing the nature of his presentation beforehand, stating:

"It would have been nice to know that when you made your application. You did not tell me that, sir" 1.

Dewald's Explanation and Intentions

Dewald, who operates a startup called Pro Se Pro, claimed that his intention was not to promote his business but to use the avatar as an aid during the proceedings 1. He cited a previous bout with throat cancer as the reason for needing assistance with extended speaking 2. However, the judge was unconvinced, noting that Dewald had already engaged in verbal conversations with court staff for over 30 minutes 2.

AI in the Courtroom: A Growing Concern

This incident highlights the growing debate surrounding the use of AI in legal settings. Recent controversies have emerged involving lawyers using AI tools like ChatGPT without realizing the potential for generating fictional case law 2. Dewald himself acknowledged the skepticism towards AI in courtrooms, mentioning concerns about "hallucinations" and false information 1.

Aftermath and Apology

Following the incident, Dewald wrote a letter of apology to the court 1. He explained to The Register that while he had initially planned to use an AI-generated avatar of himself, technical difficulties led him to use a stock avatar from a company called Tavus 12.

Implications for Future Legal Proceedings

This case raises important questions about the role of AI in legal proceedings and the need for clear guidelines on its use in courtrooms. As AI technology continues to advance, the legal system will likely face more challenges in balancing innovation with traditional court practices and ensuring the integrity of legal proceedings.

Explore today's top stories

NASA and IBM Unveil Surya: An AI Model for Predicting Solar Weather

NASA and IBM have developed Surya, an open-source AI model that can predict solar flares and space weather, potentially improving the protection of Earth's critical infrastructure from solar storms.

New Scientist logoengadget logoGizmodo logo

5 Sources

Technology

7 hrs ago

NASA and IBM Unveil Surya: An AI Model for Predicting Solar

Meta Launches AI-Powered Voice Translation for Facebook and Instagram Creators

Meta introduces an AI-driven voice translation feature for Facebook and Instagram creators, enabling automatic dubbing of content from English to Spanish and vice versa, with plans for future language expansions.

TechCrunch logoCNET logoThe Verge logo

8 Sources

Technology

23 hrs ago

Meta Launches AI-Powered Voice Translation for Facebook and

OpenAI's GPT-6: Revolutionizing AI with Memory and Personalization

OpenAI CEO Sam Altman reveals plans for GPT-6, focusing on memory capabilities to create more personalized and adaptive AI interactions. The upcoming model aims to remember user preferences and conversations, potentially transforming the relationship between humans and AI.

CNBC logoTom's Guide logo

2 Sources

Technology

23 hrs ago

OpenAI's GPT-6: Revolutionizing AI with Memory and

DeepSeek and Baidu: China's Open-Source AI Revolution Challenges Western Dominance

Chinese AI companies DeepSeek and Baidu are making waves in the global AI landscape with their open-source models, challenging the dominance of Western tech giants and potentially reshaping the AI industry.

TechRadar logoVentureBeat logo

2 Sources

Technology

7 hrs ago

DeepSeek and Baidu: China's Open-Source AI Revolution

The Rise of 'AI Psychosis': Mental Health Concerns Grow as AI Chatbots Proliferate

A comprehensive look at the emerging phenomenon of 'AI psychosis', its impact on mental health, and the growing concerns among experts and tech leaders about the psychological risks associated with AI chatbots.

Gizmodo logoFuturism logoThe Telegraph logo

3 Sources

Technology

7 hrs ago

The Rise of 'AI Psychosis': Mental Health Concerns Grow as
TheOutpost.ai

Your Daily Dose of Curated AI News

Don’t drown in AI news. We cut through the noise - filtering, ranking and summarizing the most important AI news, breakthroughs and research daily. Spend less time searching for the latest in AI and get straight to action.

© 2025 Triveous Technologies Private Limited
Instagram logo
LinkedIn logo