2 Sources
2 Sources
[1]
Britain seeks 'reset' in copyright battle between AI and creators
LONDON, Jan 13 (Reuters) - British technology minister Liz Kendall said on Tuesday the government was seeking a "reset" on plans to overhaul copyright rules to accommodate artificial intelligence, pledging to protect creators while unlocking AI's economic potential. Creative industries worldwide are grappling with legal and ethical challenges posed by AI systems that generate original content after being trained on popular works, often without compensating the original creators. Britain, which Prime Minister Keir Starmer wants to turn into an AI superpower, initially proposed relaxing copyright laws to allow developers to train models on any material they could lawfully access, with creators required to opt out. Ministers said this approach had been a mistake. Kendall told a committee of lawmakers that the publication of the government's review - due in March - would be a "genuine reset moment". She said the creative industry's two main concerns - reward for their work and control of their art - were incredibly important. "One of the things that was crystal clear in the consultation was just how important fundamentally it is for the creative sector to have those two issues at the heart of the way forward," she said. Culture minister Lisa Nandy, who appeared alongside Kendall in front of the committee, echoed that view, saying there was no single answer from contributors to the review, but the initially preferred opt-out system was widely rejected. "One of the learning points for this government has been that it was a mistake to start with a preferred model, the opt-out model," Nandy said. "We have to take a far more nuanced approach to this and work with different parts of the creative industries to address the very serious and in some cases existential challenge that is posed by the current system, let alone by any changes that we may make," she added. Reporting by Sam Tabahriti and Paul Sandle; editing by William James Our Standards: The Thomson Reuters Trust Principles., opens new tab
[2]
Britain seeks 'reset' in copyright battle between AI and creators
British technology minister Liz Kendall said on Tuesday the government was seeking a "reset" on plans to overhaul copyright rules to accommodate artificial intelligence, pledging to protect creators while unlocking AI's economic potential. British technology minister Liz Kendall said on Tuesday the government was seeking a "reset" on plans to overhaul copyright rules to accommodate artificial intelligence, pledging to protect creators while unlocking AI's economic potential. Creative industries worldwide are grappling with legal and ethical challenges posed by AI systems that generate original content after being trained on popular works, often without compensating the original creators. Britain, which Prime Minister Keir Starmer wants to turn into an AI superpower, initially proposed relaxing copyright laws to allow developers to train models on any material they could lawfully access, with creators required to opt out. Ministers said this approach had been a mistake. Kendall told a committee of lawmakers that the publication of the government's review - due in March - would be a "genuine reset moment". She said the creative industry's two main concerns - reward for their work and control of their art - were incredibly important. "One of the things that was crystal clear in the consultation was just how important fundamentally it is for the creative sector to have those two issues at the heart of the way forward," she said. Culture minister Lisa Nandy, who appeared alongside Kendall in front of the committee, echoed that view, saying there was no single answer from contributors to the review, but the initially preferred opt-out system was widely rejected. "One of the learning points for this government has been that it was a mistake to start with a preferred model, the opt-out model," Nandy said. "We have to take a far more nuanced approach to this and work with different parts of the creative industries to address the very serious and in some cases existential challenge that is posed by the current system, let alone by any changes that we may make," she added.
Share
Share
Copy Link
The British government has abandoned its controversial opt-out approach to AI copyright rules, admitting the initial proposal was a mistake. Technology minister Liz Kendall announced a policy review due in March will prioritize protecting creators' rights and fair compensation while still unlocking AI's economic potential in the ongoing copyright battle between AI and creators.
The British government has acknowledged a significant misstep in its handling of copyright rules concerning artificial intelligence, with technology minister Liz Kendall announcing a comprehensive policy reset during testimony before lawmakers
1
. The admission comes after widespread rejection of the government's initial proposal to relax copyright laws for AI training through an opt-out system for creators, a framework that would have allowed developers to train AI models on any material they could lawfully access unless creators explicitly opted out2
.
Source: Reuters
Kendall told a committee of lawmakers that the publication of the government's review, scheduled for March, would mark a "genuine reset moment" in addressing the copyright battle between AI and creators. The technology minister emphasized that protecting creators' rights—specifically reward for their work and control of their art—would be central to the way forward
1
.Culture minister Lisa Nandy, appearing alongside Kendall, explicitly stated that starting with a preferred model had been an error. "One of the learning points for this government has been that it was a mistake to start with a preferred model, the opt-out model," Nandy said
2
. She stressed the need for a more nuanced approach that addresses what she described as "very serious and in some cases existential challenge" facing creative industries.The reversal reflects broader tensions as creative industries worldwide grapple with legal and ethical challenges posed by AI systems that generate original content after being trained on popular works, often without compensating the original creators
1
.
Source: ET
Related Stories
The policy review comes as Prime Minister Keir Starmer pursues his vision of transforming Britain into an AI superpower, creating tension between fostering AI's economic potential and safeguarding the interests of AI and creators
2
. The consultation made clear that fair compensation and creative control are non-negotiable concerns for the creative sector, forcing the British government to recalibrate its approach to AI training regulations.The March policy review will need to address how to enable AI innovation while ensuring creators receive appropriate recognition and payment when their work is used for AI training. This balance will likely influence how other nations approach similar challenges, making Britain's eventual framework a closely watched test case. The government's willingness to admit mistakes and pursue a more collaborative approach with different parts of the creative industries suggests the final framework may incorporate varied solutions rather than a one-size-fits-all model, though the specifics remain to be seen when lawmakers and stakeholders review the March publication.
Summarized by
Navi
22 Feb 2025•Policy and Regulation

10 May 2025•Policy and Regulation

17 Dec 2024•Policy and Regulation

1
Policy and Regulation

2
Technology

3
Technology
