Scott Bessent Calls Out AI Industry Leaders for Alarmism Without Offering Real Solutions

Treasury Chief Challenges AI Industry Leaders on Risk Management

US Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent has sharply criticized AI industry leaders who warn of catastrophic risks but fail to propose actionable solutions. In an interview with Axios published Saturday, Bessent stated that "this alarmism without solutions by some of the AI community, that's not leadership"1

1

2

2

. His comments directly address recent warnings from prominent figures including Anthropic's Dario Amodei, OpenAI's Sam Altman, and xAI's Elon Musk, who called in September for the AI industry to slow development of its most advanced models due to growing existential risks for humanity2

2

. Microsoft co-founder Bill Gates escalated concerns further by warning the technology could cause "a billion deaths" and advocating for government regulation2

2

.

Labs Must Own Their Risks Through Self-Regulation

Bessent emphasized that managing AI risks falls squarely on the companies developing these systems. "It is the people at the labs who have to accept responsibility, and I agree with that," he told Axios1

1

. When asked about AI industry executives calling for regulation, Bessent responded bluntly: "Well, then they should slow down"1

1

2

2

. His position aligns with President Donald Trump's stance, who rejected new federal regulation during a meeting with top industry executives including Elon Musk, Microsoft CEO Satya Nadella, Meta's Mark Zuckerberg, Palantir CEO Alex Karp, and OpenAI President Greg Brockman this week2

2

. Trump endorsed using external audits to assess AI systems' safety through a non-binding accord with Silicon Valley leaders, emphasizing that "self-regulation is very important"2

2

. Bessent added that he believes "the labs have come around to that way of thinking, too"2

2

.

US-China Discussions on AI Risks and Incident Warning System

Despite emphasizing geopolitical leadership and warning that "we cannot lose our lead to the Chinese," Bessent revealed plans for unprecedented cooperation through a bilateral notification system with China1

1

2

2

. The AI incident warning system aims to reduce uncertainty, share warnings about serious incidents, and help both governments respond before an AI problem escalates or spreads globally2

2

. Bessent and Chinese Vice Premier He Lifeng discussed artificial intelligence during talks in New York in September, agreeing to create a "US-China AI dialogue" to develop a common understanding of the technology's benefits and threats2

2

. Their discussions covered critical concerns including uncontrolled AI agents and non-state actors using AI for cybersecurity or biological threats1

1

2

2

.

Chinese Models Lack Guardrails Despite Growing Capability

Bessent warned about the dual challenge posed by Chinese AI development, noting that while the US must maintain its technological edge, Chinese models present unique dangers. "A lot of these Chinese models are very powerful -- not as powerful as the US models -- but you get something that's 80%, 90% as powerful, without guardrails that can be imported anywhere in the world," he told Axios1

1

2

2

. This assessment highlights the complexity of AI governance in a competitive global landscape where technological advancement must be balanced against safety concerns. President Xi Jinping told Donald Trump during his Washington visit that China and the US can continue discussing AI, exchange views on its risks and benefits, and work together to prevent its misuse, according to China's Xinhua news agency2

2

. However, Trump stated last week he does not want an AI safety deal with China, suggesting limits to this openness1

1

. Bessent's approach advocates for "safe acceleration" where AI industry responsibility takes precedence over regulatory intervention2

2

.