AI Delivers Zero Financial Payoff Beyond Tech Giants, Says Apollo Economist

Reviewed byNidhi Govil

12 Sources

Share

Apollo Global Management's chief economist reveals AI investments have failed to boost productivity or profits outside major tech firms. While the Magnificent 7 see 30% revenue gains, the rest of the S&P 500 shows no improvement despite massive spending.

News article

AI Investments Fail to Deliver Returns Beyond Silicon Valley

Torsten Slok, chief economist at Apollo Global Management, has published findings that challenge the widespread narrative around artificial intelligence transforming business. His analysis of the S&P 500 reveals a stark divide: AI has delivered zero financial payoff to corporate America outside the tech sector, despite massive investments and widespread hype

1

. Slok's examination focuses on what he calls the S&P 493—the S&P 500 minus Alphabet, Amazon, Apple, Meta, Microsoft, Nvidia, and Tesla—finding that profit margins and revenue per worker remain flat with no evidence that AI productivity is improving business outcomes

1

.

The Magnificent 7 See Growth While Others Stagnate

The economic impact of AI appears concentrated among the Magnificent 7 technology companies, which have experienced approximately 30% growth in revenue per employee over the past four years

2

. Meanwhile, companies outside this elite group show no corresponding improvement. Profit margins tell a similar story across an even longer 11-year period, with major tech firms rising while the S&P 493 remains stagnant

2

. This disparity raises questions about whether mainstream corporations can translate increasingly cheap intelligence into higher revenue growth and profit margins

1

. Apollo Global Management manages roughly $1 trillion in assets, lending significant weight to Slok's economic assessment

4

.

Productivity Gains Remain Elusive for Most Organizations

Total Factor Productivity data reveals a troubling trend. Following an initial spike in worker output per hour in early 2023—possibly attributable to early AI adoption in industries like programming—productivity has since fallen to zero

2

. The University of Manchester's Productivity Institute examined this phenomenon in their report "The AI Ambition Gap," identifying why growing adoption of AI tools has failed to translate into forecast productivity gains

3

. One key finding: AI tools can raise productivity at individual task levels, but these gains don't automatically translate into greater productivity across entire roles or organizations

3

.

The Task-Level Versus Organization-Level Disconnect

Research demonstrates significant task-level improvements. Software developers using GitHub Copilot completed around 26% more tasks, while professionals using ChatGPT for routine writing and analysis reduced task completion time by 40% while improving output quality by 18%

3

. However, a study of AI development tools found these increased coding activity by approximately 240%, while actual software releases grew only about 30%

3

. The gap exists because humans still need to check and test work before release. Jobs typically combine automatable activities with tasks requiring judgment and accountability, coordination, client interaction, and critical thinking. As AI removes or accelerates some activities, those complementary human tasks become the constraint on time saving

3

.

Corporate America Treats AI as Cost Rather Than Growth Driver

Mainstream S&P 500 companies are pulling back on AI spending, treating token costs as expenses that weigh on margins rather than potential sources of future growth

4

. S&P Global aims for roughly 2% in annual productivity gains but cannot isolate AI's contribution from other operational changes. "Some of that is directly AI. Some of that is non-AI. Most of it is actually mixed and integrated," CFO Eric Aboaf stated

5

. Keith Waddell, CEO of staffing firm Robert Half, acknowledged the challenge: "Translating individual productivity to organizational productivity—there's a lot of slip between cup and lip"

5

. Venture-backed companies continue spending heavily on AI tokens, but mainstream organizations don't need the latest models and aren't willing to pay for them

4

.

Why AI Financial Payoff Remains Limited

Slok argues that AI may be a great calculator, but business runs on judgment, not number crunching. "AI does not understand accountability, trust, culture, unwritten rules, ethical trade-offs or fairness, all of which shape reputational risk and ultimately drive revenue growth and profit margins," he wrote

1

. Organizations have invested heavily upfront on retraining staff, reorganizing workflows, and other adjustments. Those costs appear immediately, yet payback doesn't materialize until later

3

. If AI stays confined to a small portion of the economy, its macroeconomic impact will remain very limited

4

.

Federal Reserve Data Shows Mixed Productivity Sources

The Federal Reserve Bank of San Francisco reports that increased investment and more intensive use of labor and equipment have contributed 1.3 percentage points to annual productivity growth since early 2023—nearly twice their contribution over the preceding two decades

5

. A broader efficiency measure stripping out additional capital investment effects has grown by 0.7% annually, compared with 0.5% from 2005 to 2022

5

. Some investment may be AI-related, such as software helping employees accomplish more in less time. In the Fed's Beige Book, San Francisco district businesses credited AI and traditional improvements—including training and streamlined processes—roughly equally for productivity gains

5

.

Anthropic Shows What's Possible Within Tech

Productivity gains appear more apparent among companies developing AI. Anthropic disclosed in its IPO filing that Claude wrote more than 90% of contributions to its codebase last month

5

. The average daily volume of code contributed per engineer was more than 45 times its 2024 level

5

. This demonstrates AI's potential when applied within organizations building the technology itself, contrasting sharply with adoption challenges elsewhere.

Closing the AI Ambition Gap Requires Strategic Workflow Redesign

The University of Manchester's Productivity Institute identifies several enablers to help organizations close the ambition gap. Management must set strategic direction, while strengthening worker capabilities through greater knowledge and data literacy helps turn individual insight into shared learning

3

. Organizations should implement AI governance and focus on applications creating new products, improving core processes, or solving previously intractable problems

3

. "AI's productivity potential becomes real when faster tasks lead to better performance across the business," said Bart van Ark, professor at The Productivity Institute

3

.

What Business Leaders Should Watch

The AI story will ultimately be decided by the S&P 493 rather than the Magnificent 7, according to Slok

4

. Watch whether AI's benefits spread beyond tech giants and appear in broader corporate financial results. Models might become commoditized enough for tokens to get cheap enough for revenue to grow and margins to expand, though Slok thinks that goal could be harder to achieve than it sounds

4

. Not everyone shares this pessimism—Goldman Sachs economist Jan Hatzius argues that AI investments will ultimately pay off in higher productivity and economy-wide profits

4

. Companies must treat AI as workplace redesign rather than simple technology deployment, focusing on high-value use cases linked to strategy, customer value, and operational bottlenecks

3

.

© 2026 TheOutpost.AI All rights reserved