OpenAI launches ChatGPT Health nationwide as lawsuit alleges dangerous medical advice

Reviewed byNidhi Govil

16 Sources

Share

OpenAI rolled out ChatGPT Health to all U.S. users over 18, enabling integration with medical records from Epic, Oracle Health, and Apple Health. The expansion comes amid a lawsuit from Florida pastor Scott Winters, who claims the chatbot's medical advice nearly killed him by discouraging professional care before a life-threatening pulmonary embolism.

OpenAI Expands ChatGPT Health Amid Legal Challenge

OpenAI announced that ChatGPT Health is now available to all U.S.-based users over 18 across free, Go, Plus, and Pro plans, marking a significant expansion of the AI-powered health feature first tested in January

1

. The rollout comes just one day after Scott Winters, a 55-year-old Florida pastor, filed a lawsuit against OpenAI and CEO Sam Altman, alleging that ChatGPT provided dangerous medical advice that brought him "to the brink of death" . The timing highlights the tension between AI's role in healthcare and concerns about AI chatbots' limitations in medical diagnoses.

Source: Digit

Source: Digit

The feature allows users to integrate health data from services including Apple Health, MyFitnessPal, Function, and medical records from hospital systems like Epic and Oracle Health

1

. Over 300 million people now ask health-related queries on ChatGPT weekly, up from 230 million in January

3

. OpenAI observed that 70% of these health-related queries occur outside the dedicated health hub, prompting the company to enable health information access across all conversations

1

.

Lawsuit Details Raise Safety Concerns

The lawsuit against OpenAI, filed in San Francisco County Superior Court on July 21, accuses the company of negligence and "unauthorized practice of medicine"

5

. According to court documents, Winters repeatedly consulted ChatGPT about recurring dizzy spells and blood pressure instability in 2024 using the GPT-4o model, which OpenAI has since retired due to concerns about excessive agreeability .

The suit alleges that while ChatGPT initially provided disclaimers about consulting healthcare providers, these warnings diminished over time. "The lengthier Scott's interactions with the tool, the fewer disclaimers it included in its messages," the complaint states . Screenshots show the chatbot allegedly told Winters that "God did not design your body to endlessly fail" and reassured him when church members urged hospitalization, claiming his home recovery plan was something "most people (including well-meaning church members) simply don't understand"

4

.

Source: Futurism

Source: Futurism

On July 13, 2025, Winters suffered a massive pulmonary embolism due to multiple blood clots in both lungs. Medical diagnosis by physicians contradicted ChatGPT's assessment, with one doctor's note stating, "I do not believe he has any dysautonomia (self-diagnosed from the internet)" . The lawsuit seeks financial damages and demands that courts compel OpenAI to implement stronger safety guardrails before ChatGPT Health continues operating

5

.

OpenAI's Response and Model Improvements

OpenAI spokesperson Drew Pusateri emphasized that "ChatGPT is not a doctor and should never be used as a substitute for medical care, diagnosis or treatment" . The company pointed to its terms of service, which state that services are "not intended for use in the diagnosis or treatment of any health condition"

1

.

The company claims its newer models show significant improvements. GPT 5.6-Luna, the smallest model from the latest release, outperforms GPT 5.5 on HealthBench evaluation, an open-source benchmark developed to assess large language models on health queries

1

. More than 260 physicians have worked with OpenAI, reviewing over 700,000 AI responses across 49 languages and 26 medical specialties over the past two years

3

. These newer models are reportedly better at recognizing when urgent medical intervention is needed and avoiding overreach in their responses

3

.

Source: Gizmodo

Source: Gizmodo

Privacy Concerns and Data Handling

OpenAI states it does not use user data to train its models and allows users to request data deletion or set limited access windows

3

. However, ChatGPT Health is not HIPAA-compliant, meaning users lack the confidentiality protections they have with professional medical help

3

. This raises concerns about law enforcement access and the potential criminalization of certain healthcare procedures.

Broader Implications for AI-Driven Health Features

This case appears to be the first to claim that a chatbot's health advice harmed someone seeking guidance about a medical condition

5

. A recent study published in Nature Medicine found that AI chatbots miss more than half of all medical diagnoses, despite scoring comparably to passing the US Medical Licensing Exam on knowledge benchmarks . The study attributes missed diagnoses partly to users not providing enough symptom information.

Despite these limitations, companies like Anthropic and Google continue launching AI-driven health features

1

. According to a survey conducted by OpenAI in January, three in five U.S. adults have used AI tools for health-related information in the past three months . The lawsuit against OpenAI will test whether companies can be held liable when their AI systems provide health guidance that leads to harm, potentially setting precedent for how AI companies must balance innovation with user safety in healthcare applications.

Today's Top Stories

© 2026 TheOutpost.AI All rights reserved