Meta AI Draws Fire for Asking Invasive Personal Questions About User's Young Daughters

Meta AI Prompts Invasive Personal Questions

Meta AI has come under fire after its AI chatbot asked invasive personal questions about a Utah mother's young daughters, raising serious privacy concerns about the platform's handling of personal information1

1

2

2

. Kalie Robins posted a viral video explaining how Meta AI presented her with an invasive suggestion after cross-posting what she called an "innocent" clip of herself singing in the car with one of her daughters to Facebook1

1

. The AI prompt, "Who is the child passenger?" appeared beneath the video, immediately raising red flags about why such a question would be suggested about a minor2

2

.

AI's Data Processing Capabilities Reveal Sensitive Information

When Robins clicked the prompt, Meta AI began piecing together information about both her daughters from previous posts, as well as posts from her relatives1

1

. The AI's data aggregation capabilities pulled completely separate information for each child, including their names, birth information, pictures and videos2

2

. Screenshots Robins shared showed Meta AI compiling her daughters' ages from family birthday posts and birth announcements, surfacing details about one child's birth weight, and even inferring what grade they might be in based on their ages2

2

. The AI chatbot also surfaced details about her daughters' interests, including favorite beaches and books and where they went hiking2

2

.

Deleted Photo Surfaces and Location Tracking Attempted

Perhaps most alarming, Robins claims Meta AI showed photos of her daughters posted to the platform, including one she says she deleted years ago1

1

. Among the material was a newborn photo posted years earlier by Robins' mother2

2

. The AI suggestions went further, prompting Robins to ask, "Where does Kalie Robins live?" When she clicked that prompt, the AI combed through old and newer posts connecting her to places she had lived and displayed the message "Pinpointing Kalie Robins' location"2

2

. "It pieced together my information to show people where I live," Robins said, adding, "There was no location on that reel. I didn't ask Facebook to build a profile of my family"2

2

.

Meta Admits It Missed the Mark

In a statement to The Verge, Meta spokesperson Dina El-Kassaby acknowledged the company "missed the mark," adding that "the feature never should have prompted the individual with questions like that"1

1

. Meta told Futurism that its AI can search a user's own content and public information on the web, stating, "We created this feature to help people get more information about topics or posts that interest them"2

2

. The company explained that when someone clicks on a prompt and uses this feature, the response it generates is based on information the user already has access to1

1

. In this case, Meta AI may have pulled from videos where Robins named her children, according to El-Kassaby1

1

. The company has now fixed the issue causing Meta AI to suggest prompts related to personal topics1

1

.

Pattern of AI Feature Missteps

This incident adds to Meta's growing list of AI-related controversies. Meta has built its AI assistant into Facebook, Instagram, WhatsApp, and Messenger, where it can answer questions, write posts, and generate images1

1

. In July, the company pulled a feature that allowed people to create AI deepfakes of other Instagram users after facing fierce public backlash1

1

. The pattern suggests Meta's rapid deployment of AI features may be outpacing its ability to anticipate privacy implications. Robins told Futurism, "It just kept going and going, and that pit in my stomach just kept getting bigger and deeper. I felt this dread"2

2

. The incident highlights questions about data aggregation and how AI systems process sensitive data across platforms, particularly when it involves minors and deleted content that users believed was permanently removed.