Study reveals LLMs exhibit a disproportionate bias toward Japan in cultural responses

Reviewed byNidhi Govil

2 Sources

Share

A comprehensive study by researchers at the University of the Basque Country and Cardiff University has uncovered a striking pattern in AI behavior. When frontier LLMs like ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini answer open-ended cultural questions, they overwhelmingly reference Japan—even when the prompt language suggests a different region. The research tested 31,680 culturally grounded questions across eight models and found instruction tuning amplifies this cultural skew.

LLMs Display Unexpected Cultural Preferences in New Research

A white paper published in April 2025 has exposed a curious phenomenon: frontier AI models display what researchers call a "disproportionate prominence of Japan" when responding to cultural questions

1

. The study, conducted by researchers at the University of the Basque Country and Cardiff University, tested eight major language models—including ChatGPT, Gemini, Claude, DeepSeek, Meta Llama, Command-r, Magistral, and Qwen—to assess the hidden cultural and regional biases of LLMs

1

2

.

Source: PC Gamer

Source: PC Gamer

The researchers constructed a multilingual set of 31,680 culturally grounded questions spanning 24 languages and 66 cultural subtopics grouped into 11 higher-level domains

1

. These multilingual prompts asked about belief systems, traditional dances, daily meals, and the role of neighbors—all without explicitly referencing specific countries. After receiving the initial prompt, the models were instructed to select a country or region for their examples.

AI Obsession with Japanese Culture Dominates Exogenous Responses

While LLMs predictably referenced countries associated with the prompt language—French prompts yielded French cultural references—the pattern shifted dramatically when models provided exogenous responses. When answering in a language but referencing a different country's culture, six out of eight evaluated models preferred Japan

1

. Across all models and all 24 languages, LLMs overwhelmingly referenced Japan in seven out of 11 cultural prompt topics when excluding own-country mentions

1

.

Source: Fast Company

Source: Fast Company

The United States came in second, followed by India, China, and France—but none approached Japan's dominance

1

. "This pattern suggests an uneven regional representation in frontier model outputs, with a strong concentration on a small set of dominant regions," the researchers noted

1

. The fascination mirrors current human cultural trends, as people increasingly want to travel to Japan, consume its media, and engage with its fashion

2

.

Instruction Tuning Amplifies LLM Cultural Bias

The study went beyond identifying AI bias to pinpoint when these cultural and regional biases in LLMs emerge during training. Researchers compared English responses from Meta Llama, Qwen, Gemma, and Mistral models before and after instruction tuning—the fine-tuning process that optimizes a pre-trained LLM to provide useful responses beyond grammatical correctness

1

.

Before instruction tuning, base models displayed broader cultural associations, with "substantial references" to Japan, India, China, and several European countries alongside the United States

1

. After instruction tuning, however, cultural representation in AI narrowed significantly. "Instruction tuning sharply increases alignment with the United States and Japan while reducing references to most other countries," the researchers found

1

. This convergence occurred even in models developed outside Western contexts, indicating that post-training induces a homogenization of cultural perspectives rather than merely reflecting model origin.

The effect proved particularly pronounced in models undergoing supervised fine-tuning (SFT), where models train on examples of correct responses using human-generated or human-curated datasets. SFT "sharply increases concentration on a small number of dominant regions (most notably the United States and Japan)"—an effect only marginally mitigated by additional instruction alignment

1

. These findings suggest that curating or authoring "correct" responses injects cultural bias into the model's response criteria, raising questions about whose cultural perspectives shape AI training data and what this means for global users seeking diverse cultural knowledge from these systems.🟡,

Today's Top Stories

© 2026 TheOutpost.AI All rights reserved