Talks open on whether to write binding rules for killer robots, with the US and Russia against

4 Sources

Share

A United Nations conference in Geneva opens this week to decide whether binding negotiations on lethal autonomous weapons begin. Most states support the idea; the US, Russia and Israel oppose it.

A United Nations conference opening in Geneva on Monday will decide whether countries start negotiating the first binding international rules for weapons that can kill without a human pulling the trigger

1

. The meeting, a review conference of the Convention on Certain Conventional Weapons, is due to decide whether to launch talks on a legally binding agreement covering what diplomats call lethal autonomous weapons systems

2

.

The stakes are no longer hypothetical. Advances in AI have powered drones, tanks, robots and submarines that could kill with no human in the loop

3

. Weapons with partial autonomy, assisted by AI, have already seen combat in Ukraine, Sudan and the Middle East

1

. Anna Hehir of the Future of Life Institute points to media reports suggesting fully autonomous systems have seen early combat use in Ukraine

1

.

Source: Reuters

Source: Reuters

The camps

Most of the 128 states that have joined the convention support launching those negotiations

1

. Against them stand the United States, Russia and Israel, who argue existing international humanitarian law already covers these weapons

4

. Diplomats and rights groups expect opposition from major military powers to make any binding agreement hard to reach

1

.

The camps are also split over what any talks should produce. The conference chair has put forward a two-year mandate for negotiating a legally binding protocol

1

. The US has proposed the opposite: five years of talks towards a non-binding agreement

2

. The UK, Germany and France sit between the two, proposing talks on an accord that leaves the binding question open, according to Human Rights Watch's Verity Coyle

1

.

Russia has yet to say publicly where it stands

1

. It has resisted binding proposals before, and one senior Western diplomat says it intends to keep the EU, at the talks as an observer, from taking the floor

3

.

The argument for rules

Campaigners including Human Rights Watch say such systems can act in unpredictable ways, with deadly mistakes a real risk

1

. The Red Cross counters that humanitarian law does not adequately address the specific risks these weapons carry

1

. The United Nations leadership, the Red Cross's leadership and the Pope have all publicly warned of the dangers, though none of them holds a negotiating vote

1

.

The week ahead

Two diplomats told Reuters the talks look set to be difficult, though a compromise by the end of the week is possible

1

. Everything from a binding agreement to a non-binding one to some hybrid remains on the table

1

. What the week will not settle, on the evidence going in, is the core dispute. Do machines that choose their own targets need new law, or is the old law enough? "Machines should never be allowed to decide who lives and dies on a battlefield but that is the dystopian reality that is fast approaching," said Verity Coyle of Human Rights Watch

1

.

Source: ET

Source: ET

© 2026 TheOutpost.AI All rights reserved