2 Sources
[1]
Uday Kotak's comment on valuation of India's top firms vs Anthropic sparks debate
Anthropic, the US-based company behind the Claude AI model, priced its IPO at $83 per share, above its earlier indicated range of $70-78, making it the largest IPO on record, surpassing Elon Musk's SpaceX listing in June. In a post on X today following the Anthropic IPO, Kotak Mahindra Bank
[2]
Anthropic IPO Rekindles Debate Over India's AI Ambitions
Indian AI startups raised $676 Mn across 57 deals in H1 2026, over 4X the year-ago period, but building a global AI giant will require deeper pools of capital, sustained R&D and stronger technical talent Anthropic's stock market debut has offered a glimpse of the extraordinary investor appetite
Share
Copy Link
Anthropic, the US company behind the Claude model, has listed at a valuation of about $1.5 trillion
1
2
. The price tag set off an argument in India about what Indian companies are actually worth.
Source: Inc42
The IPO priced at $83 a share, above the $70-78 range it had indicated
1
2
. The Economic Times called it the largest IPO on record, surpassing SpaceX's June listing1
. Inc42 reported the offering was oversubscribed more than ten times2
.The argument started with Uday Kotak, founder of Kotak Mahindra Bank and a veteran banker. In a post on X, Kotak claimed Anthropic's valuation exceeds the combined market cap of India's ten biggest listed companies
1
2
. Kotak also noted the company did not exist about five years ago1
2
. His question, as he put it: "Are we undervalued, or do we need to catch up in the new world? Or both?"2

Source: ET
The most prominent rebuttal came from Adani Group chief financial officer Jugeshinder (Robbie) Singh, who called the IPO a "textbook category error in asset pricing"
2
. Singh argued India's blue chips are yield vehicles that monetise the physical economy. Frontier AI firms, in his framing, are priced on the potential output of autonomous AI agents, a notion he called synthetic gross domestic product2
. "India's blue chips are neither undervalued nor 'behind' -- they are yield vehicles monetising the physical human economy," he wrote2
.Ex-Infosys CFO Mohandas Pai dismissed Kotak's comparison itself. "Every disruption creates new companies with huge valuations. It is the nature of markets," he said, adding that comparing is silly
2
. For scale, $1.5 trillion works out to roughly 37% of the $4.06 trillion in gross domestic product the IMF projected for India in its October estimates2
.The debate lands on hard numbers about India's own AI ambitions. Indian AI startups raised $676 million across 57 deals in the first half of 2026, more than four times the $162 million a year earlier. One deal, Sarvam AI's $234 million raise, inflated the total
2
. Broader Indian startup funding actually fell 9% year on year to $5.2 billion in the same period, so AI rose against a falling market2
. Those totals remain small next to the global leaders. OpenAI has raised a reported $112 billion, and Anthropic itself raised $65 billion just weeks before, in May 2026, at a post-money valuation of close to $965 billion2
.Chetan Mehta of Aum Ventures had sounded the same caution in July, before the IPO. "What has been raised in India is still very minuscule compared to global AI investments," he said. "The increase is encouraging, but we are still very early in this journey."
2
Government policy is part of the debate's backdrop. In one Inc42 survey, 66% of institutional investors said the IndiaAI Mission, whose approved outlay exceeds ₹10,372 crore, influenced their investment thesis
2
.The debate has landed where Pai pointed it: at what India must do to produce a company like Anthropic. The question Inc42 frames is whether India can move beyond building products on top of existing foundation models and fund deeptech that takes years to build. It points to openings in AI applications, enterprise software and robotics
2
. Chetan Mehta of Aum Ventures said, "Gone are the days when you could just build wrappers on top of foundational models. You have to build vertically focused products that solve real problems with an AI-first approach."2
Related Stories
Summarized by
Navi
10 Nov 2026•Business and Economy

21 Aug 2026•Business and Economy

11 Aug 2026•Business and Economy
