Embark Studios pulled a recap video of The Finals' APAC Closed Qualifier within a day of publishing it, after the human casters it left out called out the studio for replacing them with the game's AI commentators

2

1

.

Source: PC Gamer

Source: PC Gamer

The video, posted on the game's official social channels, was narrated by Scotty and June, The Finals' fictional in-game commentators, rather than the casters who had called the matches

2

1

. Embark, the developer of The Finals and Arc Raiders with a documented pattern of using AI voice work built on paid voice actors, said it picked the familiar characters to draw casual players into its esports scene ahead of the upcoming Grand Major

2

1

. The characters' voices belong to human actors Embark pays; the lines themselves are generated by text-to-speech from a model trained on those actors' voices

2

.

The AI quoted the humans it replaced

That last detail is where the anger concentrated. Proto, a caster who worked all four cycles of The Finals competitive circuit this year, said the AI commentators even repeated lines from the human broadcast. "After four cycles, open/closed [qualifiers], the time, effort, passion, and emotion myself, @TheeHyperactive, and @bluepanda_casts put in, we get replaced by two AI casters who even quote us. I get they are a part of the game, but yikes," Proto wrote

2

.

Per Proto's account, the studio did not feed the broadcast footage into the AI. It selected clips, wrote an original script for Scotty and June, and reused things the casters had said, which is why the AI echoed them

2

.

The objection spread well past the two affected casters. Marvel Rivals caster LemonKiwi called the move appalling. Fighting-game commentator Damascus described training AI on actual casters as devious, and League of Legends caster Sam "Initialise" Hapgood branded it dystopian

2

1

. Bluepanda, who has cast for nearly seven years, said she is done with the game and esports altogether. "For nearly seven years I've been repeatedly told that my work is valued and appreciated, only to then have the same people saying those things turn around and either completely ghost me or tell me they're going in a different direction with talent and that my services aren't needed. GG," she said

2

.

The reversal, and the apology that didn't land

Embark deleted the video and cancelled two more recaps, planned for the American and European qualifiers in the same format, saying all three were being rethought

2

1

. The reversal came after the affected casters aired the grievance publicly and prominent casters from other games joined in

2

1

. Oscar Lundberg, the studio's community and competitive operations lead for The Finals, apologized on X, calling the omission of the casters a mistake: "Yesterday we released a recap of the APAC Closed Qualifier that left out the casters and talent who made that event. That was a mistake, and I'm sorry"

2

.

The people the apology addressed did not accept it. "Embark saw no issue with this until they received overwhelming global backlash and even then their response was essentially, 'Whoopsie, we didn't think people would mind'," Bluepanda said

2

.

What the casters want next

The recap was not a one-off experiment. A Dynamic Commentary feature announced in October already let Scotty and June name players and call out in-match events. Embark also defended AI voice lines in its other game, Arc Raiders, earlier in November, saying voice actors would go crazy reading every item and location variant

2

1

.

Proto warned the episode could let tournament organizers conclude they can drop paid talent for a cheaper AI substitute. He is calling for an industry-wide union or contract protections, including bans on using voices in generative AI, covering production staff too

2

1

. "Opening that door is almost like Pandora's Box," he said

2

. A few commenters saw the move as a predictable extension of Embark's known approach to AI, so the talent's position is not universally shared

1

. Proto's proposed fix is contractual: "We'll turn around and say, 'We're not doing this until people send us contracts that essentially ban the use of our voices in generative AI'."

2

© 2026 TheOutpost.AI All rights reserved