Etsy sellers are deleting their shops over a new AI training clause

4 Sources

Share

Some Etsy sellers are closing their shops in protest at a new clause in the marketplace's terms that gives the company and its partners the right to use their listings to train AI. Etsy is known as a home for handmade goods sold by independent creators, per the Times and Engadget, and some of the sellers leaving ran their shops for a decade or more.

2

1

The clause is the trigger sellers name for their departures, a link all three outlets report.

3

2

1

Source: NYT

Source: NYT

What the clause says

The clause sits in part 5, section C, of the Terms of Use and takes effect December 16. It grants Etsy, along with its third-party partners and vendors, permission to use sellers' content to build, train, test and refine AI and machine learning technologies. The previous version of the terms carried no AI clause at all, so the right itself is new.

2

1

The clause also includes a waiver of sellers' moral-rights claims.

3

Source: The Next Web

Source: The Next Web

Etsy says the change merely clarifies how it already uses AI, which it presents as making the platform better and safer.

3

2

1

James Ossman, an Etsy VP, posted a public response: "We do not use your content to train AI models designed to copy your original work or replace your creativity."

3

He says the actual uses are automatic translation of listing descriptions and featuring listing photos in marketing.

3

1

He points, too, to seller tools such as listing optimization and stats summaries.

3

1

He also says Etsy blocks AI crawlers from scraping listings and shares data with partners only for fraud detection and for helping buyers find sellers' items off Etsy.

1

Source: Engadget

Source: Engadget

The gap between the promise and the contract

The trouble, per PC Gamer's reading of the text, is that the binding clause does not contain the limits Ossman described.

3

PC Gamer also reports there is apparently no opt-out available at all, even though the clause points to opt-out rights in Etsy's Privacy Policy. Critics say the training should require sellers to opt in rather than being switched on by default.

3

And per the same outlet's reading, the anti-scraping rule binds users and unauthorized third parties, while Etsy's own licensed partners fall outside it.

3

Sellers say they will not let years of creative work train AI systems or be resold, with no way to decline.

2

Illustrator Aaron Millard deleted the shop he had run for nearly a decade. "Etsy decided that selling on their platform now means letting them train AI on our artwork AND resell that data to third parties, with no way to opt out," he wrote on Instagram. "My work took years to learn and create. I won't let it be stolen."

2

The longest-tenured departure named in the coverage is Cognitive Surplus, a home goods and stationery brand. It deleted its shop after 13 years on Etsy, accusing the company of claiming "perpetual, free, boundless permission" over its art.

2

The timing stings, too. Weeks before the backlash, Etsy banned AI-generated recipes and patterns, a move Ossman framed as necessary to build trust in the platform.

3

The site has separately drawn recent criticism, per Engadget, for letting mass-produced and drop-shipped items flood the marketplace.

1

PC Gamer asked Etsy whether the policy might change and had received no reply as of November 20.

3

Kristen Zephyrus, Cognitive Surplus's co-founder, put the leaving side of it plainly. "For Etsy to be helping to train algorithms with our human content is just unimaginably awful," she told the Times. "We don't want anything to do with that."

2

© 2026 TheOutpost.AI All rights reserved