Lumentum's chief executive has admitted investors are unhappy with the company's $115 billion sale to Marvell, even as he argues the combination is stronger than either company alone.

Source: Benzinga

Source: Benzinga

Michael Hurlston told Semafor the deal has been "a rough go" and hasn't worked as he expected

1

. Speaking to Jim Cramer of the financial news channel CNBC, he said: "Shareholders are not happy ... It's been a tough couple of weeks"

2

. The market agrees with the shareholders. Marvell has fallen roughly 45% and Lumentum 42% since the Oct. 28 close, when Bloomberg first reported the deal talks

2

. The selling was still running on Friday, with Lumentum down more than 6% in premarket trading

2

.

Why the selloff shrinks the deal itself

Marvell agreed on 2 November to acquire Lumentum, which makes lasers and optical components for AI data centers, in an all-stock deal valuing it at $115 billion including debt

1

. Because the deal is all stock at a fixed ratio of 4.5 Marvell shares per Lumentum share, every drop in Marvell's price cuts what Lumentum holders stand to receive

1

. The declines come amid a broader slide in AI-related semiconductor stocks and worries about how long the AI boom lasts, so the pain is not all deal-specific

1

2

.

There is also little Lumentum can do about it. Hurlston says Lumentum's ways out are few: shareholders voting the deal down, or regulators blocking it, are just about the only things that could undo it

1

. Bloomberg analysts have questioned whether the deal closes at all, pointing to uncertainty around China's regulatory review

2

. If it does close, Marvell holders would end up with roughly 67% of the combined company, and closing is expected in the first half of 2028

2

.

The defense, and what could turn it around

He told interviewers Lumentum had spent months seeking a chip business to buy, and that Marvell was the best option it found in the field

1

. "Their numbers are phenomenal. Our numbers are phenomenal, and we feel the combination is even more powerful," he told Cramer

2

. He also pointed to a strategic bet: AI data centers are shifting from copper to fiber-optic connections, a transition he says could become an important growth engine for the merged company

2

. Lumentum's latest quarter gives the numbers side some support: adjusted earnings of $4.57 a share beat the $4.19 estimate on revenue of $1.263 billion, and Hurlston says demand has seen no slowdown

2

.

His pitch to investors now rests on upcoming disclosures he says could reassure them: Marvell's earnings on Dec. 1, Lumentum's own results and the merger filing known as an S-4. He says stronger financial results from both companies could restore their valuations and show, in his words, that "there's nothing wrong here"

2

. He concedes the persuading is unfinished: "We've got work to do with our shareholders"

2

.

That report is the first of the reassurance events Hurlston named, and the first real test of whether the numbers can do what his interviews have not. Analysts expect Marvell to report earnings of $1.09 a share on revenue of $3.16 billion, up from 76 cents and $2.08 billion a year earlier

2

.

© 2026 TheOutpost.AI All rights reserved