3 Sources
[1]
New York bill would punish judges who misuse AI
Nov 17 (Reuters) - New York judges who include made-up information in rulings could face sanctions or a referral for impeachment under new proposed legislation in the state. In at least three cases, judges in the United States have acknowledged that rulings they issued contained AI-generated
[2]
New York Bill Would Punish Judges Who Misuse AI
Nov 17 (Reuters) - New York judges who include made-up information in rulings could face sanctions or a referral for impeachment under new proposed legislation in the state. In at least three cases, judges in the United States have acknowledged that rulings they issued contained AI-generated
[3]
New York bill would punish judges who misuse AI
Nov 17 (Reuters) - New York judges who include made-up information in rulings could face sanctions or a referral for impeachment under new proposed legislation in the state. In at least three cases, judges in the United States have acknowledged that rulings they issued contained AI-generated
Share
Copy Link
A New York state senator has introduced a bill that would treat fabricated, AI-generated material in court rulings as judicial misconduct
2
. Michelle Hinchey, a Democrat in the state Senate, put the Judicial AI Accountability and Integrity Act forward on Monday1
.
Source: Reuters
The bill says a state judge or justice who "knowingly or recklessly" includes fabricated legal authority in a ruling would be deemed to have engaged in misconduct
2
. Using AI by itself would not constitute misconduct under the proposed law3
.It could also send a misconduct finding to state legislators, who could weigh impeachment
1
. Impeachment referral is the harshest penalty the bill contemplates3
. It is proposed legislation, not law, and the commission did not immediately answer a request for comment2
.In at least three US cases, judges have said their rulings included AI-generated fake citations or other fabricated material
1
. According to state records, an Oklahoma judge acknowledged that a ruling he issued included AI-generated fake citations2
. Two federal judges, one in Mississippi, one in New Jersey, told Senate Judiciary Chairman Chuck Grassley last year that staff had used AI on court orders he deemed "error-ridden"3
. Last month the 5th US Circuit Court of Appeals reassigned one of those cases away from the judge3
. At least some lawyers nationally have faced discipline or scrutiny over similar mistakes1
.New York's court system already issued guidance on AI use by judges and court staff last year, part of a small group of states with any AI-specific rules for legal work
3
. If passed, it would be, per the report, the first state law in the country aimed specifically at judges who misuse AI2
. California's first-of-its-kind law regulating generative AI use by lawyers and arbitrators takes effect in January .Related Stories
Summarized by
Navi
[2]
[3]
06 Mar 2026•Policy and Regulation

09 Jun 2026•Policy and Regulation

07 Jun 2025•Technology
