In March 2026, students at Transylvania University, a tiny liberal-arts college in Lexington, Kentucky with under 1,000 students, petitioned the administration to cancel the school's chatbot licenses with major AI companies and spend the money on what the petition called human-centered education

1

2

. About a third of the student body signed

1

2

.

Source: NYT

Source: NYT

The trigger, students said, was money. The student newspaper had reported the university paid $120,000 for licenses to ChatGPT and Gemini

2

. Alice Beatty, then a senior, helped lead the drive after joining a discussion group formed by AI-skeptical professors

2

. By her account, when she and classmates collected signatures near the dining hall, almost everyone they spoke to signed. Some peers told her, "I use AI, and I am ashamed I use it"

2

.

The conscientious objectors

The petition is the opening example of a wider student resistance movement to AI on campuses

1

2

. Polls show a vast majority of American students use chatbots for schoolwork, and college leaders have generally embraced AI as key to workforce preparation

1

2

. Against that, resisters from California to Sydney to Paris are publishing manifestos with three demands. They want no college partnerships with AI companies and no requirement that professors use generative AI in teaching or grading. They also want a student right to refuse chatbot-required assignments without grade penalties

1

2

.

The opposition draws mostly from the political left, citing environmental harm, threats to workers and military uses of AI, and the loudest voices come from arts and law students

1

2

. A core worry is that AI removes the productive struggle of learning

1

2

.

The refusal is organized beyond students. Emily Tucker, executive director of Georgetown Law's Center on Privacy and Technology, put her name to an open letter alongside 1,300 other educators refusing generative AI adoption in schools

2

. She says AI degrades students' ability to read dense legal texts and risks incorrect case-law citations. She concedes AI can help with some tasks, like searching within a large set of documents

2

. At the University of Kentucky, one research employee obtained a religious exemption from using AI

2

. At Cornell, which announced free AI access for students in October, psychology professor Shimon Edelman lets his students choose but called using AI in his own research "unthinkable"

2

.

Students say the split runs through social life too. Several said friend groups often settle on a shared view of AI. "If you can't generate a coherent thought without ChatGPT, I genuinely lose a lot of respect for you," said Emmali Simmelink, a senior at Whitman College who raises AI's environmental impact whenever she hears someone mention the tool

2

.

Colleges begin to respond

Georgetown University began offering free Gemini access in March, letting each professor set their own AI rules. Its own focus groups found 40% of student sentiment toward AI cautious or negative against 25% positive or hopeful, and its student newspaper editorialized against the license

2

. This fall, under new president Eduardo Peñalver, Georgetown announced a faculty committee to draft AI-use principles, clearer course expectations, tech-free spaces and more weight on oral presentations and in-person tests

2

. Peñalver said the changes are meant to make course AI expectations more transparent and protect in-person learning, while expanding access because the tools have potential to do good

2

. He also said an encyclical Pope Leo XIV recently wrote on AI's risks will be an important influence at the Jesuit institution. "We're not interested in pushing people to use AI in ways that don't align with their values," he said. "But I certainly encourage people to learn about it"

2

. The university is continuing to expand free AI access, the same policy its student newspaper editorialized against

2

.

Transylvania, for its part, declined an interview but said professors remain free to embrace, limit or ban AI in their own classes, and no licenses were canceled

2

.

Colleges should fix how they assess students rather than push adoption, she argues

2

. "There is silence about these major tech issues," she said, "students just seeing grown-ups being inconsistent and letting them down"

2

.

© 2026 TheOutpost.AI All rights reserved