Judge lets consumers sue Samsung, Micron and Hynix over the RAM price spike

7 Sources

Share

A federal judge has ruled the memory price-fixing lawsuit against Samsung, Micron and SK hynix can proceed. The case alleges coordinated production cuts drove memory prices up, but nothing has been proven and prices are unlikely to fall soon.

A federal judge has ruled that Samsung, Micron and SK hynix must face a lawsuit accusing them of working together to drive up memory prices, rejecting the companies' bid to have the case thrown out

5

. The November 14 decision means the three companies that dominate the world's memory chip market will have to defend the allegations in court rather than escape at the threshold

5

.

Source: Wccftech

Source: Wccftech

Seventeen consumers and small businesses in five US states filed the case, Garciaguirre v. Samsung Electronics, on June 25, 2026

3

. The complaint puts the three companies' combined share at more than 91% of global revenue for this kind of memory chip in the third quarter of 2025

7

. It alleges the three began cutting conventional memory output in late 2022 and, from 2023, steered wafer capacity toward high-bandwidth memory for AI chips

7

. Conventional memory prices then allegedly rose by up to 697% over 18 months

7

. There is a physical reason the AI pivot squeezes ordinary buyers. High-bandwidth memory takes three to four times the wafer area per gigabyte compared with standard PC memory

5

. Every wafer turned toward AI chips is one not making consumer memory

5

.

Source: TweakTown

Source: TweakTown

Why the judge let it stand

Judge Noël Wise of the Northern District of California found the complaint plausibly alleged an agreement outlawed by Section 1 of the Sherman Act, pointing to parallel conduct that goes beyond what competitors in a concentrated market would ordinarily be expected to do

5

. Her order points to a string of moves hard to explain without a prior understanding: Samsung and SK hynix refusing long-term contracts with conventional memory buyers, plus delayed or halted factory construction

7

. All three companies also wound down production of an older memory type in the same quarter of 2025

7

. Micron announced on December 3 that it would shut down its 30-year-old Crucial consumer brand

7

. In January 2026, all three adopted near-identical customer-vetting questionnaires asking buyers about their end customers, order sizes and the demand behind them

5

.

"But Plaintiffs' allegations go beyond hawks watching each other; their contentions are more akin to hawks flying in formation, an activity that hawks ordinarily do not do," Wise wrote in her order

5

.

The companies argued their conduct was an independent, legitimate response to AI demand in a highly concentrated market

3

. They also called the suit a rerun of a 2016-2018 case the Ninth Circuit dismissed in 2022

3

. The judge rejected both arguments in her November 14 order, writing on the comparison: "The Court finds that it is not."

7

History hangs over the case. In a 1998-2002 memory price-fixing conspiracy, Samsung and SK hynix pleaded guilty and paid fines of $300 million and $185 million respectively, per one outlet

4

. Micron avoided penalties by cooperating and received immunity

4

. It is the third time in roughly three decades the three companies have faced price-fixing accusations; a similar 2018 suit was dismissed for lack of evidence, with that dismissal upheld on appeal in 2022

1

.

Nothing proven yet

A ruling at this stage settles nothing: the plaintiffs still have to prove an agreement existed, and companies behaving in parallel is not automatically illegal under US antitrust law

3

. All three companies deny wrongdoing

3

. The complaint also alleges the companies passed up hundreds of millions to billions of dollars in additional annual profits by keeping output restricted

6

. The plaintiffs argue such foregone earnings point to coordinated behavior

6

.

Source: GamesRadar

Source: GamesRadar

Why prices may not fall soon

Even a courtroom win would not make memory cheaper quickly; a lawsuit in itself adds no production capacity. SK hynix's chief executive has said the memory shortage could last through 2030

3

. Micron, meanwhile, has signed pricing-guarantee deals locking in memory costs at 2026 levels for some clients until at least 2031, per one report

4

. Today's high prices are thus already written into contracts, whatever happens in court

4

. The manufacturers must file their formal responses to the complaint by December 7, 2026, and a first case-management conference is set for January 12, 2027

7

.

© 2026 TheOutpost.AI All rights reserved