Ohio Man Becomes First Federally Convicted for Deepfake Porn Under Take It Down Act

First Person Federally Convicted Under New Deepfake Law

James Strahler II, a 37-year-old from Columbus, Ohio, has become the first person federally convicted under the Take It Down Act after pleading guilty to charges including cyberstalking, producing child sexual abuse material, and publication of digital forgeries 1

1

. The federal conviction marks a significant milestone in the enforcement of legislation targeting deepfake porn and the nonconsensual sharing of AI-generated intimate images. According to the Department of Justice, Strahler had at least 10 victims, including children, making this case particularly severe 1

1

.

The Take It Down Act, enacted in 2025, criminalizes the distribution of non-consensual explicit or intimate imagery, including AI-generated deepfakes. This law banning AI deepfakes imposes prison sentences of up to two years for depictions of adults and up to three years when minors are involved 1

1

. The legislation also requires online platforms to remove reported material within 48 hours, a provision set to take effect next month 2

2

.

Disturbing Scale of AI-Generated Abuse Material

Investigators discovered that Strahler used artificial intelligence software to produce explicit deepfakes involving both adults and minors. He manipulated real images of individuals from his community, sometimes children he personally knew, and blended their likenesses into graphic scenes 2

2

. The resulting material consisted of more than 700 images and animations, which were distributed on a website dedicated to child sexual abuse content 2

2

.

When authorities seized Strahler's phone last year, they uncovered a digital cache of more than 2,400 explicit photos and videos, many generated with AI-based image tools. His devices contained evidence of more than two dozen AI platforms and over 100 online models used in the production process 2

2

. This extensive use of generative AI highlights the misuse of generative AI as a tool for exploitation and digital harm.

Cyberstalking and Targeted Harassment

Beyond creating child sexual abuse material, prosecutors revealed that Strahler engaged in cyberstalking by targeting at least six adult women. He sent them sexually explicit AI-generated images and, in one instance, a fabricated video depicting a victim in an incestuous act that was reportedly shared with her coworkers 2

2

. A woman contacted police in Hilliard, Ohio, after she and her mother began receiving texts, voice mail messages, and obscene photos from unknown numbers. Some messages included rape threats from Strahler, according to an FBI agent's criminal complaint 1

1

.

Dominick S. Gerace II, the U.S. attorney for the Southern District of Ohio, stated: "We will not tolerate the abhorrent practice of posting and publicizing A.I.-generated intimate images of real individuals without consent" 1

1

. This strong statement signals the federal government's commitment to prosecuting digital forgeries and revenge porn cases.

Growing Crisis and Legislative Response

The case emerges amid rising concern over the misuse of generative AI to create child sexual abuse material. In 2025 alone, the National Center for Missing and Exploited Children received more than 1.5 million tips related to AI-generated content, illustrating how synthetic imagery has complicated law enforcement's efforts to combat online exploitation 2

2

. These staggering numbers demonstrate the scale of the problem facing authorities.

Congress continues to explore additional measures to address this growing threat. The ENFORCE Act, which passed the Senate late last year, aims to subject creators and distributors of AI-generated child sexual abuse material to the same penalties as those who produce real imagery 2

2

. Meanwhile, at least 45 states have enacted their own laws targeting intimate deepfakes and related technologies 2

2

.

Melania Trump, the first lady, supported the Take It Down Act's passage by speaking at a roundtable on Capitol Hill and appearing alongside President Trump when he signed the bill into law 1

1

. With the Strahler conviction, the federal government has delivered its first test case for how artificial intelligence, once hailed purely for innovation, is now being scrutinized as a tool of digital harm and a new frontier for enforcement 2

2

. Legal experts will be watching closely to see how severe a sentence Strahler receives, which could set precedents for future prosecutions involving AI software and non-consensual content.