Meta Faces CMA Investigation Over Exploitative AI Training Terms for Publishers

Reviewed byNidhi Govil

10 Sources

Share

The UK's Competition and Markets Authority has launched an investigation into Meta over proposed commercial terms that could allow the tech giant to scrape publishers' content for AI training without adequate choice. Meta paused the rollout after facing global regulatory pushback, including a temporary ban in Norway and legal setbacks in France.

CMA Opens Formal Investigation Into Meta's Commercial Terms

The Competition and Markets Authority has launched a formal investigation into whether Meta is abusing a dominant position by imposing exploitative terms on publishers and advertisers

1

. The probe will examine Meta's commercial terms that could allow the company to collect content from publishers' websites and use it to develop its own products and services, including AI features, without businesses getting a choice on if or how their content is used

2

. The CMA announced the case on October 30 under the Competition Act 1998, acting on concerns from stakeholders including the News Media Association and the Movement for an Open Web

2

.

Source: The Next Web

Source: The Next Web

"Digital platforms play an important role in helping UK businesses reach millions of customers around the world. But where a company holds a dominant position, it must not use that position to impose unfair terms," said Sarah Cardell, the CMA's chief executive

2

. The investigation will first determine whether Meta holds a dominant position in a relevant UK market and, if so, whether the terms amount to abuse of that position

1

.

Meta Pauses Controversial Terms Amid Regulatory Scrutiny

Meta has put the rollout of its revised commercial terms on hold following widespread backlash and regulatory scrutiny

3

. The company initially planned to introduce the changes on October 30, then pushed the date to November 20 after engaging with the CMA

4

. On October 28, Meta announced a pause pending consultation with industry groups

1

.

The proposed terms would have required business accounts to allow Meta to "use any content from such domains, web pages, or URLs to provide, develop, improve, research, train, and maintain the integrity of" Meta's products

3

. The terms give Meta permission to deploy bots, web scrapers and other automated tools to crawl the domains and web pages linked to a business account, with no compensation offered for extracted content

4

.

A Meta spokesperson stated there were "no grounds" for an investigation, adding: "We've already committed not to change our terms without consulting publishers and other stakeholders. We welcome the opportunity to explain our approach to the CMA"

2

. Meta spokesman Andy Stone previously wrote that the update was meant to let Meta pull accurate product information from third-party sites for ads and recommendations, "not about scraping news sites"

4

.

Global Pushback Against Meta's Use of Publishers' Content for AI

The CMA investigation represents just one front in a growing global battle over Meta's data usage practices. A Norwegian court ordered a temporary halt to the terms on October 28, responding to a petition from 180 Norwegian media companies supported by the Norwegian Media Businesses' Association

4

. The injunction remains in force until the legality of the terms has been thoroughly evaluated

4

.

Source: Market Screener

Source: Market Screener

In France, the country's appeals court rejected Meta's attempt to overturn an order to negotiate in good faith with French media over rights payments for information used on its social networks

5

. In two rulings, the Paris Appeals Court found that Meta's conduct had caused "serious and immediate harm to the press sector" in France, affirming the position of the country's anti-monopoly body

5

. The court found that Meta had provided only fragmentary, opaque and unverifiable data about its use of media content during negotiations with publishers

5

.

The European Commission held talks with Meta about the proposed terms and was glad to see them delayed, with Commission spokesperson Sara Simonini stating the Commission remains determined to hold Meta's conduct to the standards of EU law

4

.

Industry Response and Implications for Generative AI Development

The Movement for an Open Web called the pause and the CMA investigation a "significant win"

4

. "Unless the CMA and other regulators make it abundantly and quickly clear that this sort of anti-competitive landgrab is not acceptable, then we will continue to see the tech giants throwing their weight around in this way," said Tim Cowen of the group

4

.

The CMA's concern centers on the fact that thousands of UK businesses rely on Meta to reach customers and audiences, meaning an unfair imposition of the new terms could breach competition law

5

. The watchdog said the terms could amount to an unlawful imposition of unfair trading conditions on thousands of UK businesses

2

.

Since May this year, more than 340 local and national news sites including the Guardian, the New York Times and USA Today have blocked internet archive crawler bots to prevent them from collecting data for training AI models

5

. This growing resistance from publishers signals a broader industry pushback against tech platforms using media content for generative AI development without proper compensation or consent.

Separately, the CMA is asking Meta for information about Meta One, its business subscription service, following concerns from the Federation of Small Businesses about small firms posting external links on Facebook and Instagram without paying for a subscription

2

. Meta has not been designated with strategic market status under the UK's new digital markets regime, which gives the CMA wider powers, though the CMA board is due to consider its next proposals for that status in spring 2027

2

.

© 2026 TheOutpost.AI All rights reserved