Wikimedia Foundation Proposes Middle Ground in OpenAI Copyright Lawsuit Over Fair Use and AI Training

Reviewed byNidhi Govil

7 Sources

Share

The Wikimedia Foundation filed an amicus brief in the New York Times lawsuit against OpenAI and Microsoft, proposing that AI model training on copyrighted material constitutes fair use, but retrieval-augmented generation systems that reproduce content should require licensing. The nonprofit warns that extreme rulings could either stifle innovation or threaten the open web.

Wikimedia Foundation Stakes Middle Ground in Landmark AI Copyright Case

The Wikimedia Foundation filed an amicus brief Friday in the US District Court for the Southern District of New York, entering the high-stakes copyright battle between The New York Times and OpenAI

1

. The nonprofit organization behind Wikipedia is urging the court to adopt a nuanced approach to fair use doctrine, warning that an overly simplistic ruling could either threaten technological innovation or endanger the collaborative model that sustains open knowledge platforms

2

.

"We are taking a position in this case to defend the free and open human knowledge that Wikipedia depends on," said Wikimedia Foundation CEO Bernadette Meehan

3

. The foundation's roughly 5,800-word brief argues that both parties in the lawsuit push "overbroad and simplified applications of the fair use doctrine" around AI copyright

1

.

Source: Engadget

Source: Engadget

Training Models Versus Reproducing Content: A Critical Distinction

The Wikimedia Foundation proposes splitting the AI copyright question into two distinct scenarios. The organization argues that scraping websites and using copyrighted works to pre-train large language models should constitute fair use when they provide "something new and different from the original sources"

1

. According to the brief, pretraining creates transformative outputs that don't simply replace the original works

4

.

However, the foundation draws a sharp line at retrieval-augmented generation, or RAG, where AI chatbots copy text from websites like Wikipedia or The New York Times to answer user queries

4

. When these models pull copies of material and deliver it to users "while supplanting readers' engagement with those original works," that should require licensing

1

. "While the pre-training of ChatGPT's general LLM was fair use, OpenAI's use of copies in ChatGPT's RAG feature is not fair," Wikimedia stated in the brief

4

.

Wikipedia's Existential Stakes in the Ruling

Source: Benzinga

Source: Benzinga

The ruling carries existential implications for Wikipedia. Wikimedia websites "have become one of the most critical sources of data for all artificial intelligence and machine learning training," the organization acknowledged in its filing

1

. Wikipedia is considered one of the highest-quality datasets for training LLMs, with more than 67 million articles in roughly 300 languages contributed by approximately 250,000 volunteers each month

5

.

Yet these same AI systems siphon away visitors, undermining the communities that maintain these sites

1

. Wikimedia argues that services like ChatGPT violate copyright by reproducing text licensed under Creative Commons without adhering to the license terms, which require attribution and share-alike treatment for adaptations

1

. For Wikipedia, this means crediting the original source under its Creative Commons CC BY-SA 4.0 licensing, which also requires "any remix or adaptations" to remain under that same license

1

.

Balancing Innovation With Attribution Requirements

Despite its concerns about content reproduction, the Wikimedia Foundation acknowledges that large language models provide valuable tools for Wikipedia's mission. LLMs help editors fight vandalism, detect copyright violations and doxxing, and identify articles needing improvement

1

. "It would be contrary to the purposes of copyright law to block these capabilities by labeling LLM development as categorically not fair use," the brief states

3

.

"A ruling that does not apply fair use principles carefully could threaten the sustainability of free knowledge, and stifle the development of open source technologies, ultimately impacting access to information for everyone in both cases," said Wikimedia Foundation General Counsel Stephen LaPorte

2

. The foundation emphasizes that intellectual property conversations around AI copyright "cannot be limited to for-profit organizations: it must include stakeholders across the entire online information ecosystem"

5

.

Implications for the Broader Copyright Landscape

Source: The Next Web

Source: The Next Web

The New York Times lawsuit, filed in December 2023, alleges that OpenAI and Microsoft illegally used millions of copyrighted articles to train their AI chatbots

3

. OpenAI has characterized content regurgitation as "a rare bug," while Microsoft argued in a September filing that expert analysis found Copilot rarely reproduces full sentences from news content

1

.

This case is just one of over a dozen similar lawsuits working through the courts. In June, nearly 400 local newspapers sued OpenAI and Microsoft, and in September, the Justice Department sided with OpenAI, telling the court that AI model training is fair use

4

. A summary judgment is expected in the near future, which could set an important precedent for how courts interpret fair use in the age of artificial intelligence

2

.

Wikimedia's proposed framework reflects the foundation's February 2025 partnerships with Amazon, Meta, Mistral, Perplexity, and Microsoft, through which companies pay to use Wikipedia content for training new models

3

. The foundation also highlighted that scraping strains its servers, pushing it to add technical safeguards that bad actors often circumvent, and noted that rogue OpenAI agents had edited its wikis without approval this month

4

. Judge Sidney H. Stein will decide whether to accept the brief and ultimately rule on whether using copyrighted content to build large language models constitutes fair use under US law

4

.

© 2026 TheOutpost.AI All rights reserved