Christmas adverts have become an awkward test of honesty this season. Some brands are quietly using AI in them, others are loudly advertising that they did not, and audiences have started checking the hands in the animation for themselves

1

2

.

Source: The Conversation

Source: The Conversation

The quiet camp

Audiences have grown vigilant about AI in advertising after earlier backfires, and that vigilance now falls on everything from obvious computer-generated imagery to hand-drawn animation. McDonald's pulled an AI-generated Christmas ad in the Netherlands after three days last year when viewers learned the AI use had gone undisclosed. Coca-Cola's 2025 festive campaign drew similar criticism over AI scenery and animals many found uncanny

1

2

.

This year, Very and Plusnet went ahead with AI-produced Christmas ads anyway. UK law does not require on-screen disclosure, so their AI use appears in press releases and trade announcements rather than in front of viewers

1

2

. The company has not said why it keeps the disclosure off-screen, and UK law gives it no reason to put it on. EU transparency rules do restrict undisclosed AI content, but they stop at the border

1

2

.

That does not make the practice safe: the UK Advertising Standards Authority still prohibits ads that mislead by omission, including where one falsely implies human creation to deceive viewers

1

2

. And AI can hide in plain sight. Royal Mail's 2025 ad used traditional live-action footage, but it emerged only later that the voiceover was AI-generated

1

2

. Replacing performers this way feeds anxiety in the industry and beyond, echoing the fears behind the 2023 Hollywood writers' and actors' strikes

1

2

.

Even Dior got checked

The sharpest case this year was Dior's Christmas short, a hand-drawn film directed by French animator Sylvain Chomet, with a cast including Rihanna and Robert Pattinson, about Christian Dior's friendship with Marlene Dietrich

1

2

. Some viewers suspected AI generation anyway, pointing to fingers that looked missing and strange hand transitions

1

2

. Dior published a behind-the-scenes page on its website highlighting the actors and design sketches to ward off AI accusations, and commenters praised the film's authentic look

1

2

.

Chomet and producer Aton Soumache told Variety the film was drawn by hand and that generative AI played no part in it, with interpolation confined to the "repetitive, mechanical part of animation, not the creative work"

1

2

. They called automated interpolation "a very small part of the process"

1

2

. The denial is qualified, because interpolation is a tool that predates AI but now often involves it, so the line the audience cares about has blurred

1

2

.

Selling the human hand

A counter-trend has followed: some brands now sell the human hand behind their campaigns. Prada emphasises traditional hand-drawn animation in a behind-the-scenes video. Barbour and Thatchers Cider hired Aardman, the studio behind Wallace & Gromit, to hand-animate their ads. Etsy titled its campaign "celebrate being human"

1

2

. Some video game studios have gone further and detailed their refusals to use generative AI at all

1

2

. The author reads the craft trend as a response to the ethical and aesthetic problems undisclosed AI ads create

1

2

.

The praise those traditional campaigns received suggests, at least to the author, that audiences still care deeply about craft

1

2

.

© 2026 TheOutpost.AI All rights reserved