2 Sources
[1]
Why using a chatbot as your lawyer is a risky move - and ties up our court system
In the Federal Court of Australia, applications by self-represented litigants, many using artificial intelligence (AI) to research and draft their claims, have skyrocketed. The Fair Work Commission, a federal tribunal, has already seen a jump in filings, many of them "AI slop". These experiences
[2]
Why using a chatbot as your lawyer is a risky move -- and ties up our court system
In the Federal Court of Australia, applications by self-represented litigants, many using artificial intelligence to research and draft their claims, have skyrocketed. The Fair Work Commission, a federal tribunal, has already seen a jump in filings, many of them "AI slop." These experiences are
Share
Copy Link
Australian courts and tribunals had identified 295 cases, up to September 30, 2026, in which AI use in legal proceedings went wrong: invented case citations, real citations that had nothing to do with the argument, witness statements and submissions drafted by a chatbot that were simply inaccurate
1
2
. The count comes from a research centre that runs a global database of AI-related court cases1
2
.
Source: The Conversation
Self-represented litigants account for 81% of those cases, and their number rose sharply over the past year
1
2
. The burden falls mostly on people navigating court without a lawyer.The consequences can be financial. In Sadnan Khan v Aldi Pty Ltd, the Fair Work Commission ordered a former Aldi employee to pay A$1,230 in costs after his AI-reliant unfair dismissal claim failed. It also refused him leave to appeal
1
2
. The commission found he had relied on AI-generated arguments in a claim he should have realised was hopeless, an unusually heavy step for the tribunal1
2
.The volume is being felt system-wide. The Fair Work Commission has seen a jump in filings, many of which its observers describe as "AI slop"
1
2
. The Federal Court has seen a surge of applications from self-represented people using AI to research and draft claims1
2
.Per recent Federal Court data, a high proportion of that increase is appeals from people who already lost in a lower court or tribunal
1
2
. Failed claims are therefore climbing the court hierarchy and multiplying the work. That climb also raises the stakes for the litigants. Losing in a higher court can cost money in a way lower tribunals often do not. The loser-pays rule often applies there, meaning the losing side covers the winner's legal bills1
2
. Two unpublished papers using US civil court data point the same way: AI-related filings by self-represented people are up, but win rates show no apparent change and remain low1
2
.Related Stories
The Fair Work Commission issued guidance on responsible generative AI use, effective October 20, 2026, covering the importance of real legal sources and how to prompt a chatbot more effectively
1
2
. Most Australian courts have now released similar guidance, and courts internationally face the same pressures; Singapore's courts are exploring AI-powered tools for small-claims users1
2
. The authors describe a pyramid of responses: education and guidance at the base, then corrections such as amend-and-refile orders and warnings. Above those come deterrents, including striking claims out, filing restrictions and costs orders, up to contempt sanctions at the top1
2
.Warnings and sanctions alone are unlikely to fix this, the authors argue, because people like what the chatbot gives them. Generative AI produces fluent arguments faster than a human could, and people like its responses
1
2
. Chatbots, they argue, are more sycophantic than people and have no duty to act in a client's best interests, unlike a lawyer, who must sometimes deliver an unwelcome opinion1
2
. A chatbot, they note, is free and always available, while a lawyer costs money and works by appointment. Until that changes, they expect courts to keep seeing filings like these1
2
.
Source: Phys.org
Summarized by
Navi
[1]
08 Oct 2025•Technology

26 May 2026•Entertainment and Society

09 Nov 2025•Policy and Regulation
