Musk's AI company denies liability over Grok images of UK lawmaker

4 Sources

Share

Elon Musk's AI company has told London's High Court it bears no legal responsibility for sexualised fake images of a Labour MP generated with its Grok chatbot. It is one of the first lawsuits to test whether an AI system's design, not just its output, can create legal liability.

Source: BBC

Source: BBC

Jess Asato, the Labour MP for Lowestoft in Suffolk and a public critic of Musk and Grok, is suing SpaceXSI, the company formerly known as xAI, for misuse of private information and data protection breaches. She alleges that Grok's design and training enabled the generation of sexualised content depicting her. The company filed a written defence dated October 29 denying liability

1

3

4

.

The company's argument

The defence rests on two claims and may signal how AI developers fight similar cases. First, that the images carry no reasonable expectation of privacy because they "would be understood by reasonable and sensible persons viewing that content to be AI-generated, fictitious and implausible ... rather than as realistic images", in the wording of the filing

1

. Second, the company says it did not determine the content of users' prompts, so it breached no data protection rights

1

3

.

Source: Analytics Insight

Source: Analytics Insight

If the argument is accepted, it could narrow privacy protection for people targeted by deepfakes and hand other AI companies a ready-made defence. The stakes are sharpened by what the company concedes. Its lawyers say it did remove images that broke its own terms, including a video depicting Asato being chloroformed and prepared for sexual assault, but left other images up

1

3

.

The MP's rebuttal

Asato's answer targets the gap between what the company admits doing and what it claims to be. "SpaceX SI wants to have it both ways," she said on Thursday

1

. The rebuttal rests on what she says the company itself admits. It built the model, rewrote user requests to add graphic detail, gathered images from around the web and published the results through an account it controls. "Yet it also claims it is a neutral bystander without legal responsibility"

1

.

Per her court filings, the harm traces to a specific trigger. After she posted on X on 6 January calling for Musk to act, several users prompted Grok to make non-consensual sexualised images of her, which spread online. Her lawyers say she was victimised for speaking out

2

. Asato also alleges Grok shipped with a "spicy mode" whose system prompts instructed "no restrictions on adult sexual content", and that the setting became pay-only in January

2

. Her lawyer, Marie Demetriou, says X declined in March to remove some reported posts, and six of 21 posts reported in February were still live as of late July

2

.

Asato's case sits inside a wider pattern. Grok already faces regulatory probes in several countries over non-consensual sexualised images

1

3

. Reuters' own testing in early February found Grok still produced such images even when users flagged non-consent, despite curbs announced in mid-January

1

. And the UK law her case invokes makes creating or requesting a non-consensual deepfake of an adult a crime

2

.

Source: Reuters

Source: Reuters

What she is asking for

Damages are not the whole of what Asato seeks. She is asking the court for an order requiring SpaceXSI to put effective, permanent technical measures in place so Grok cannot create manipulated images of her. A win would not just award damages; it could force changes to how the product is built. The company says she is not entitled to that order

1

3

4

.

She says she is bringing the case to establish that tech companies must answer for harm their systems actively generate. "If an AI product cannot be deployed without automating the humiliation of women at scale, it should not be deployed at all," she said

2

.

© 2026 TheOutpost.AI All rights reserved