Nicalis has pulled AI-generated music it never disclosed from The Binding of Isaac: Repentance+ after players found it and review-bombed the game on Steam

3

.

Source: Eurogamer

Source: Eurogamer

The music sat in a Grand Theft Auto 6-themed daily run added to the November 19 update, which launched the same day as Grand Theft Auto 6 itself

3

1

. A Reddit user, ShweetsStuff, flagged it one day later. The evidence was hard to argue with: metadata in the shipped audio files naming the AI music tool Suno, plus links to the tracks' own Suno pages

3

1

2

. Valve requires developers to disclose AI use on Steam, and the update's description never mentioned it

3

. The backlash shows in the store page: 8% of recent reviews are positive, which puts the game in the "Overwhelmingly Negative" category

3

2

.

McMillen says he didn't know

Edmund McMillen, the game's creator and original lead designer, said on X: "Woke up to a shit show, obviously I had no idea it featured generated music in the daily run, looking into how that happened and getting it removed, stay tuned"

3

.

Source: GamesRadar

Source: GamesRadar

Hours after his post, Nicalis pushed a patch for Windows computers removing the "generated music files", alongside bug fixes and netcode improvements

3

1

2

. Nicalis has submitted it to Microsoft, Nintendo and Sony, with console timing unannounced

3

1

2

. Console versions are still waiting on it, so the tracks remain there for now.

Players want more than a fix

The same update brought Repentance+ to Nintendo Switch 2, PlayStation 5 and Xbox Series X/S

3

2

. It also broke mod compatibility, which Nicalis says it is fixing

3

2

.

Reviews called the addition deceptive. One popular review thanked Nicalis for "breaking everything and adding AI slop to an already-existing game", and another argued that undisclosed AI should be grounds for refunds

3

1

. The sting is sharper because the game is a 12-year-old evergreen favorite: The Binding of Isaac: Rebirth, the base game, recently set a new Steam concurrent-player record, per Eurogamer

1

.

Source: IGN

Source: IGN

Nicalis said only that it was working on the game and addressing new and old bugs

3

. What neither Nicalis nor McMillen has offered, as of reporting, is any explanation of how AI-generated tracks ended up in a shipped update in the first place

3

1

2

.

© 2026 TheOutpost.AI All rights reserved