States Compete for Data Centers Amid AI Boom, Facing Legislative Challenges

The Data Center Gold Rush

The explosive growth of data centers, fueled by the rising demand for artificial intelligence and cloud computing, has sparked a fierce competition among states to attract these facilities. This surge in activity was particularly ignited by the late 2022 debut of OpenAI's ChatGPT 1

1

. States are rolling out extensive financial incentives, often worth tens of millions of dollars, in hopes of securing what they see as an economic bonanza 2

2

.

The Allure of Data Centers

Advocates argue that data centers bring significant benefits:

1. Massive construction jobs during the building phase
2. Substantial spending on local goods and vendors
3. Strong tax revenues for local governments

Andy Cvengros, who leads the data center practice at commercial real estate giant JLL, emphasizes the importance of tax exemptions: "It's often a nonstarter if you don't have them, for at least the hyperscalers. It's just such a massive impact on the overall spend of the data center" 3

3

.

Legislative Efforts and Incentives

Several states have taken legislative action to attract data centers:

• Kansas approved a new sales tax exemption for data center construction and equipment 4

  4

  .
• Kentucky and Arkansas expanded existing exemptions to qualify more projects 4

  4

  .
• West Virginia created "microgrid" districts free from local zoning and electric rate regulations 5

  5

  .
• Utah and Oklahoma passed laws facilitating direct power procurement for data centers 5

  5

  .

The Pushback

However, this rush to attract data centers is not without controversy. Some lawmakers and communities are pushing back, citing concerns over:

1. Disproportionate use of resources (land, electricity, water)
2. Limited long-term job creation
3. Potential burden on local infrastructure and utilities

In Oregon and Georgia, lawmakers are advancing legislation to ensure data centers pay for the power infrastructure they require [6]. Virginia's Governor Glenn Youngkin vetoed a bill that would have mandated more disclosures about noise pollution and water use from data center developers [6].

The Energy Dilemma

The energy demands of data centers are a particular point of contention. In South Carolina, recent legislation to speed up power plant construction for data centers faced opposition. Senate Majority Leader Shane Massey expressed concern: "I do not like that we're making customers pay for two power plants when they only need one" [7].

Texas, which experienced a deadly winter blackout in 2021, is grappling with how to protect its electric grid while still attracting data centers. A proposed bill to expedite direct connections between data centers and power plants has drawn criticism from business groups [8].

The Path Forward

As states continue to compete for data center investments, they face the challenge of balancing economic opportunities with resource management and community concerns. The ongoing debate reflects the complex interplay between technological advancement, economic development, and environmental stewardship in the age of AI and cloud computing.