2 Sources
[1]
Apple commenter John Gruber makes blistering attack on 'rotten' Apple
John Gruber is one of the more high-profile Apple commenters, and generally takes a pretty upbeat view of the company, so it was a big surprise to see him launch a blistering attack on the iPhone maker. Referring to Apple advertising Siri features which don't yet exist, he argues that the company
[2]
Apple is lying about Apple Intelligence, claims Gruber
John Gruber (far right) with Greg Joswiak (left) and Craig Federighi (center) after WWDC 2024 -- image credit: John Gruber Long-time Apple pundit John Gruber has launched an uncharacteristically strident attack against what he says are Apple's lies over the Apple Intelligence roll-out. And, he's
Share
Copy Link
Apple's reputation takes a hit as prominent tech commentator John Gruber criticizes the company for overpromising on AI features and damaging its credibility. The delay in delivering advanced Siri capabilities raises questions about Apple's AI strategy and leadership.

In a surprising turn of events, Apple, a company known for its reliability and innovation, has come under fire for overpromising and underdelivering on its artificial intelligence (AI) features. John Gruber, a prominent Apple commentator, has launched a scathing critique of the tech giant, accusing it of making "bullshit" claims and squandering its reputation
1
2
.Apple recently admitted that three new Siri features, which were meant to make the virtual assistant truly intelligent, would be delayed indefinitely. These features include:
The company has quietly removed an iPhone 16 advertisement promoting these features, although they continue to be advertised on Apple's website with new disclaimers
1
.John Gruber, typically known for his positive outlook on Apple, has taken an uncharacteristically harsh stance. He argues that Apple's credibility has been severely damaged, stating:
"What Apple showed regarding the upcoming 'personalized Siri' at WWDC was not a demo. It was a concept video. Concept videos are bullshit, and a sign of a company in disarray, if not crisis."
1
Gruber further claims that Apple has pitched a story that wasn't true, and some within the company must have known this
2
.The delay in delivering these AI features has raised questions about Apple's overall AI strategy and its ability to compete in the rapidly evolving AI landscape. Critics point out that Apple has gone from being a leader in intelligent assistants in 2011 to a laggard in 2025
1
.Gruber draws parallels between this situation and Steve Jobs' handling of the MobileMe fiasco in 2008. He suggests that CEO Tim Cook should take similar decisive action:
"Tim Cook should have already held a meeting like that to address and rectify this Siri and Apple Intelligence debacle. If such a meeting hasn't yet occurred or doesn't happen soon, then, I fear, that's all she wrote."
1
Related Stories
This incident has broader implications for the tech industry, particularly in how companies communicate about AI advancements. It highlights the challenges of balancing innovation promises with realistic delivery timelines, especially in the competitive AI space
2
.While Apple has moved "fixer" Kim Vorrath to oversee Apple Intelligence and Siri, the company faces an uphill battle in regaining trust and delivering on its AI promises
2
. The tech community will be closely watching Apple's next moves, particularly how it addresses these criticisms and whether it can accelerate its AI development to match competitors.As the AI race intensifies, this setback for Apple serves as a cautionary tale about the risks of overpromising in the fast-paced world of technology innovation.
Summarized by
Navi
[2]
1
Technology

2
Policy and Regulation

3
Technology
